
What the Ingredient List Can’t Tell You
The INCI list on the back of a jar is precise, standardised and legally required. It is also silent on most of what decides whether a product works. A guide to reading it, and to its limits.
URenew (via amazon.co.uk)
Turn over almost any moisturiser sold in Britain and the back panel offers a paragraph of small type that begins with Aqua and runs through names such as Glycerin, Cetearyl Alcohol and Sodium Hyaluronate. This is the INCI list, from the International Nomenclature of Cosmetic Ingredients. The names are published by the Personal Care Products Council, a US trade association, whose database offers more than 30,000 of them. The point of the system is that the same substance carries the same name on a jar in London, Paris or Seoul, so that a dermatologist, a regulator or a shopper with an allergy can find it.
It is one of the more successful pieces of standardisation in consumer goods, and very few shoppers use it. In a YouGov poll of 1,007 British adults in March 2026, only 29 per cent said they checked ingredients often or always, though 61 per cent said they were concerned about ingredient safety and 54 per cent wanted clearer, easier-to-understand labels. In a OnePoll survey of 2,000 British women for the skincare brand Skin Rocks, published in July, 81 per cent could not say what ceramides do and 86 per cent did not know what niacinamide is mainly used for. Ceramides and niacinamide are two of the most heavily marketed ingredients of the decade.
So the list is accurate and largely unread. The harder problem is that even a trained reader learns less from it than the format suggests.
What the list does tell you
It tells you what is in the product, by standard name. That matters most for people avoiding a specific substance, such as a fragrance allergen or a preservative they react to. It also lets a reader check a claim against the formula: a product sold on its niacinamide content should list niacinamide.
Behind the list sits a body of law that most shoppers never see. Under the UK Cosmetics Regulation, every cosmetic on the British market needs a Responsible Person, a named company or individual legally accountable for its safety. That party must hold a Product Information File, including a safety assessment, and must notify the product to the Office for Product Safety and Standards before it goes on sale. If a product causes a serious undesirable effect, it must be reported. Those are the requirements the London cosmetic scientist Rinki Pramanik set out for small brands in an episode of her YouTube channel, INCI with Rinki, in March 2025, under a description that began: “Is your cosmetic product truly compliant, or are you just hoping no one checks?”
What it does not tell you
How much. Outside a few regulated substances, the list does not give percentages. A “with retinol” product might contain a clinically meaningful amount or a trace.
Which version. One INCI name can cover materials with different sources, purities and behaviour. Pramanik’s column series for Cosmetics Business, “Bench to bottle”, has made this its subject. Writing in October 2026 about PDRN, a mixture of DNA fragments traditionally purified from salmon or trout and now sold as a regenerative skincare active, she reported that “After reviewing more than 50 PDRN technologies and finished products, I found marine DNA, recombinant sequences, bacterial fermentation, microalgae and plant-derived nucleic acids carrying the same four letters, despite not being biologically interchangeable.” Her starting question for any such product is simple: “Is this real PDRN?”
Exosomes, the year’s other fashionable active, present the same difficulty from the opposite direction. Reporting from in-cosmetics Global in Paris in April, she wrote that “every supplier had their own interpretation of what an exosome should be.”
Whether it works in this formula. An ingredient’s reputation is often built in a different setting from the one on the shelf: injected rather than applied, tested on damaged tissue rather than healthy skin, or studied at a concentration no cream would use. Pramanik describes PDRN as an ingredient that exposes “the distance between an exciting mechanism and a proven topical benefit.” Delivery, pH, the other ingredients and the packaging all decide whether an active reaches skin in a useful form. None of that appears on the label.
Whether the evidence fits the claim. The list says nothing about testing. The instruments that can test cosmetic claims exist and are routine in good laboratories. Pramanik summarised them in an interview with NutraIngredients in March: “Hydration can be measured using corneometry. … Elasticity can be assessed by observing how skin returns to shape after deformation. Barrier function can be estimated through TEWL.” TEWL is trans-epidermal water loss, the rate at which water escapes through the skin. A brand that has measured these things can say so; a brand that has not can still print an impressive list.
Whether it can be made at scale. A novel active is only useful if it can be bought, stabilised and filled reliably at commercial volume. “If it is not scalable across 50,000 units, then it really loses its purpose,” Pramanik told BeautyMatter at the Paris show. The shopper never sees the actives that failed that test, only the ones that passed and the marketing that went with them.
“Clean” has no INCI name
The words that do the most commercial work on beauty packaging are often not ingredient names at all. In the YouGov poll, 32 per cent of British adults said they had switched to products they perceived as more “natural” or “clean”. Neither word is an ingredient, and neither appears in the INCI list. The list can tell a reader that a product contains no parabens; it cannot tell them whether the replacement preservative is better.
Ingestible beauty adds another layer of confusion. Collagen drinks and ceramide jellies are sold as food supplements, so their labels follow food law, not the cosmetic INCI system. The market is large and growing: a 2026 report from in-cosmetics, citing Mordor Intelligence, puts global nutricosmetics at about US$9.4 billion. Pramanik, whose employer Urenew Beauty UK sells an oral ceramide product, has argued that the category is “moving away from broad promises of ‘beauty in a bottle’ toward more specific, biologically framed benefits such as hydration support, barrier resilience, or microbiome balance.” Whether a given product meets that standard is, again, not something the label shows.
Two rulebooks, one list
Since Brexit, the list on a British product answers to British law, which no longer changes in step with the EU’s. In 2026 the EU banned a new group of substances classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic to reproduction from 1 May; the UK’s equivalent took effect on 15 August, alongside a ban on the UV filter 4-MBC from 15 July and a cut in the threshold for formaldehyde warnings from 0.05 per cent to 0.001 per cent, according to the law firm Mishcon de Reya. Northern Ireland follows the EU. The trade body CTPA says 65 per cent of the UK’s cosmetics imports come from the EU. For several months in 2026 the same product could be compliant in one market and not yet in the other.
Further changes are scheduled. Under the EU’s microplastics restriction, rinse-off cosmetics containing intentionally added microplastics may be sold until 16 October 2027, leave-on products until 16 October 2029, and make-up, lip and nail products until 16 October 2035, according to the European Commission. Each deadline will change thousands of formulas, and therefore thousands of lists.
How to read one anyway
Start with the claim on the front, then look for the ingredient that is supposed to deliver it, and ask three questions the label will not answer: how much, in what form, and tested how. Brands that know the answers tend to publish them. Pramanik put her version of the method in the plainest terms in her October column. When a new ingredient lands on her desk, the first thing she asks is whether it is what its name says it is.
Sources
- PCPC On-line InfoBase (30,000+ INCI names) (opens in a new tab)
- YouGov, 20 May 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- OnePoll for Skin Rocks, via TheIndustry.beauty, 7 Jul 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- INCI with Rinki, Episode 20, 4 Mar 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Cosmetics Business, “Bench to bottle”: PDRN, 12 Oct 2026: cosmeticsbusiness.com/pdrn-skin-care-what-the-science-r… (opens in a new tab) ; exosomes, 16 Sept 2026: cosmeticsbusiness.com/bench-to-bottle-exosomes-skin-car… (opens in a new tab)
- NutraIngredients, 31 Mar 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- BeautyMatter, 3 May 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- in-cosmetics / Mordor Intelligence, “Go for glow” (2026) (opens in a new tab)
- Mishcon de Reya, 13 Mar 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- CTPA, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- European Commission, microplastics restriction (opens in a new tab)
- URenew ceramide product listing (food supplement) (opens in a new tab)
