Energy & Climate
COP31 talks stall as latest draft omits fossil fuels
Nearly 200 countries remain split, and the revised text has also dropped a $120bn adaptation-finance target.
Video: DW News / YouTube
By the numbers
Figures from this story's sources.
- Adaptation finance target dropped from the revised text Source for $120bn (opens in a new tab)
- $120bn
- Electricity share of final energy consumption by 2035 in the draft Source for 35% (opens in a new tab)
- 35%
- Substantive agenda items counted before the talks opened Source for 102 (opens in a new tab)
- 102
Talks at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, have gone into overtime with nearly 200 countries still deadlocked. Al Jazeera reports that the latest draft no longer mentions fossil fuels.
The two-week talks were due to end on Friday. Al Jazeera reports that a late session approved some technical matters but not the wider political deal.
Australia, co-host and lead negotiator, opened with a Monday draft calling for a faster fossil fuel phase-out. A slimmer Thursday text dropped every fossil fuel reference once Saudi Arabia and other large oil and gas producers pushed back, Al Jazeera reports.
The draft proposes electricity at 35% of final energy consumption by 2035. Al Jazeera says the 35% electricity target does not require renewables; Politico says it includes fossil-fuel power. Al Jazeera adds that some countries want "clean" wording. Carbon Brief reports the 35% electrification target may be included in the planned cover text.
“We didn't come here to beg”
The draft also calls for scaling up carbon capture against a specific target. Some countries call that costly and unproven, Al Jazeera reports. France's ecological transition minister, Monique Barbut, said France is "completely opposed" to any quantified carbon capture objective, Politico reports.
Al Jazeera reports the revised text dropped a $120bn target for helping poorer countries adapt to climate change. Ghana's environment minister, Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings, said: "We didn't come here to beg." Inside Climate News reports Panama, which negotiates inside a Latin American coalition of developing countries, has threatened to stop any final text from being adopted.
In a letter dated 19 November, written on behalf of the EU's 27 member states by the bloc's climate chief, Wopke Hoekstra, and Ireland's climate minister, Darragh O'Brien, the bloc said it cannot back consensus on a package it describes as a step backwards, Politico reports.
Why it matters
In our reading, the central question for oil and gas boards is whether a COP text names fossil fuels at all, and Al Jazeera reports producers resisted similar language at COP28 in 2023. For utilities, the 35% electricity figure is unclear on power source, so any plan that relies on it carries wording risk until the text is settled. For carbon-capture developers, some countries call the target costly and unproven, so it is not yet a firm policy anchor. For companies in poorer markets, the $120bn adaptation gap remains open, and the sources do not say how it will be resolved.
What’s next
AFP expected a third draft on Saturday, according to Al Jazeera.
Sources
Checked against 4 outlets
- Al Jazeera — Deadlock and overtime, removal of fossil fuel mentions after producer objections, the $120bn finance drop, the 35% target wording, the carbon capture criticism, and the Ghana quote
- Politico Europe — Power source of the 35% target, the carbon capture target, the French position, and the EU letter of 19 November
- Inside Climate News — Panama's position within a Latin American developing-country coalition and its threat to block a final text
- Carbon Brief — Count of 102 substantive agenda items before opening, and that the 35% electrification target may be included in the planned cover text