Outgrace, home

Policy & Geopolitics

Xi, Trump and Putin to meet in Shenzhen on Thursday

China confirmed the meeting on Monday, but sources disagree on what China has said the three leaders will discuss.

China confirmed on Monday, through a Foreign Ministry spokesperson, that Xi, Trump and Putin will meet in Shenzhen on Thursday. CNBC reported it would be the first-ever gathering of the three leaders. Xi has met Trump three times since October last year, CNBC reported. The meeting sits on the sidelines of an APEC meeting in the city.

Beijing has said little. Business Standard reported that China calls the meeting of "groundbreaking significance". CNBC and the Japan Times both say China gave no topics. The Economic Times reported a different account: that China named world peace, denuclearisation and the Iran conflict, and that Ukraine was expected to be avoided. The sources disagree, and the reporting does not settle it.

The White House has its own account. Olivia Wales, a White House spokeswoman, told CNBC that Trump will take up nuclear arms reduction, and said he believes proliferation is a serious risk. A White House official told CNBC that Trump will raise the U.S.-Israeli war against Iran but is not expected to raise Russia's war in Ukraine.

“whose proliferation President Trump believes is very dangerous”

Olivia Wales, White House spokeswoman · CNBC (opens in a new tab)

Ukraine talks run in parallel. CNBC reported that Putin told U.S. envoys in Moscow last week that Europe should decide whether it wants peace or war. Russian aide Yuri Ushakov said the Shenzhen talks would continue efforts to settle the war.

CNBC reported that the U.S.-China trade truce expires in January and that an extension is widely expected. Beijing's exports to Washington have grown at double-digit rates for most of this year, from a low base, CNBC reported. CNBC's analysis expects the Nvidia chip-smuggling issue, which involves a suspected Chinese spy, to stay off the agenda.

Analysts quoted by CNBC are sceptical. Neo Wang of Evercore ISI named the disagreement over the agenda as the main hurdle. David Roche of Quantum Strategy said China will not engage in disarmament talks until it reaches parity with the U.S., about 10 years away. Robert Kagan of the Brookings Institution said China and Russia could grow more aggressive if they see Trump as politically weakened.

Why it matters

CNBC's analysts expect little concrete output from the meeting, and the trade truce expiring in January is likely to be the main commercial timing point. CNBC's analysis expects the Nvidia chip-smuggling issue to stay off the agenda, so chip supply chains get no stated outcome from Thursday. The packet reports no sanctions outcome, and Neo Wang said a joint statement on Russia sanctions looks unlikely. For companies with China trade or chip exposure, the reporting points to January rather than Thursday as the date that matters.

What’s next

The meeting takes place on Thursday in Shenzhen, according to CNBC.

Sources

Checked against 4 outlets

  • CNBC — Meeting date and venue, APEC link, first-ever description, White House and official accounts, trade truce timing, export data, Nvidia agenda expectation, analyst views, midterm context
  • Business Standard — China's description of the meeting as having groundbreaking significance
  • The Economic Times — Reported Chinese agenda of world peace, denuclearisation and Iran conflict, and expectation that Ukraine is avoided
  • The Japan Times — Confirmation of the summit and report that Beijing gave no topic details

Found something wrong? Our corrections policy explains how to tell us. How we report the news. Add Outgrace as a preferred source on Google.