Reported debt, covenant headroom and IFRS 16: what to verify first
European regulators set out what issuers should disclose about IFRS 16. Our sources do not give the arithmetic, so start with the standard and the credit agreement.
IFRS 16 is the standard that governs lease accounting, and it is the reason a lease can now change the debt figures a board reads. European securities regulators treated it as a common priority for the 2018 financial statements, ahead of its entry into force in 2019. The sources we could check say what regulators expected companies to disclose. They do not say how the numbers move, and this piece will not pretend otherwise. Read it as a guide to what is established, what is not, and what to do before a lender asks.
How it works
The honest starting point is what we could not verify. The IFRS Foundation's homepage, which we checked, carries no text of the standard, no description of lease liabilities or right-of-use assets, and no leverage or covenant figures. It shows sign-in, subscription and cookie notices. The IASB's educational material did not appear in any source we held. So this piece does not say how a lease is measured, how the new liability is calculated, or where it sits in the balance sheet. Anyone who answers those questions from memory is giving an opinion, and a board should treat it as one.
What the regulators did say is narrower. ESMA's 2018 enforcement priorities named IFRS 16 Leases as a common priority for 2018 financial statements. It expected all issuers to disclose the expected impact of the change. It also said enforcers would collect data on how listed companies applied their priorities, and would report the findings in its report on 2019 enforcement activities. The expectation is therefore about disclosure first. A company that cannot yet say what the standard will do to its numbers has not met it.
A second strand is easy to miss. ESMA also cited its Alternative Performance Measures guidelines as a separate 2018 requirement for the parts of annual reports that sit outside the financial statements. Those guidelines do not discuss leases. In our judgement, they are relevant to adjusted leverage and covenant metrics, because many companies report a leverage figure that is not an accounting line at all. A finance lead should check which of the company's ratios are alternative performance measures before assuming that the standard's arithmetic is the only figure a reader sees.
The timing also needs care. IFRS 16 came into force in 2019, according to ESMA, and the 2018 statements are now historical documents. Any current figure has to come from current filings and the standard itself. Our sources include nothing from the years since, so they cannot tell you what a company's leverage looks like today or how analysts have treated the change since.
Who it affects
The sources name one group clearly: listed issuers in the European enforcement scope. ESMA singled out issuers that would be significantly impacted, and encouraged them to say what information would let analysts and other users update their models. That is an instruction about disclosure, aimed at the companies whose figures move most. It does not say which sectors those companies are, and our sources name none. A capital-intensive business with a long property portfolio and a light one with a few vehicles would both need to ask the question, and only the first might have a large answer.
Lenders appear in our sources only in one context. The Bank for International Settlements' Basel Committee principles treat credit risk as the chance that a borrower does not honour what it agreed to. They address adequate provisions, asset quality and the disclosure of credit risk, and they apply to all lending where credit risk is present. They contain no lease-specific guidance. A lender's reading of a covenant is therefore set by the credit agreement itself, which in our judgement matters far more than the general principles when a covenant is tested.
What leaders get wrong
- Treating the change as a footnote. ESMA expected issuers to disclose the expected impact, so the explanation belongs in the reporting itself, and the finance team should not leave it until the board asks.
- Assuming every company is hit the same way. ESMA singled out issuers that would be significantly impacted, which in our judgement suggests the effect depends on how much a company leases. Build your own figure before you accept anyone else's.
- Reading the headline covenant and skipping the definitions. The definitions say what counts as debt and what counts as earnings. A new lease line either fits those definitions or it does not, and the answer is on the definitions page.
- Taking an old model into the lender call. Lenders and analysts will ask for the bridge from the old figure to the new. A model that cannot produce the bridge loses the conversation before it starts.
- Letting the change arrive as a surprise. A company that tells its lender early, with a clear explanation, is in a stronger position than one whose ratio moves in a quarterly pack and forces a call.
What to do about it
Start with the primary text. Obtain the standard itself and the IASB's educational material, and have the finance lead rebuild the leverage figures in the company's own model from those documents, not from a secondary summary. Only when that model is checked should a number go on a page that anyone outside the company will read. An accountant should confirm the treatment, because the rebuild depends on judgements the standard itself sets out.
Next, read the credit agreement's definitions page for each facility. For every covenant, write down how it defines debt, how it defines earnings, and whether it refers to the accounting standard as it stood when the agreement was signed or as it stands now. Agreements can be drafted either way, in our judgement, so the wording decides which applies. A lawyer should confirm the reading, and a lawyer should be asked whether any consent or waiver is needed before the first reporting date that carries the new figures.
Then prepare the lender conversation as a bridge, not a surprise. Show the old figure, the new figure and the difference, line by line, and state plainly that the cash the business pays under its leases has not changed. Ask the lender directly how the agreement treats the change, and put that question in writing. Send the bridge before the reporting period, not with it, so the lender has time to read the definitions and raise questions before the numbers are public. Ask for the answer before the board pack goes out, not after.
Finally, apply the test ESMA put in plain words. Could an analyst or a lender update their own model from what you publish? If the answer is no, the disclosure is not finished, and the gap is usually a missing bridge, a missing definition or a missing note on which measures are alternative performance measures.
Issuers that will be significantly impacted are also encouraged to consider what information would enable analysts and other users to update their models.
