Outgrace, home

What EU data says about green claims and shopper trust

The Commission's own figures show how many green claims and labels fall short. The consumer-survey evidence a leader would want is missing from the sources.

Shoppers in the EU meet green claims on almost every label, and the European Commission's own green claims page says a large share of them are not sound. According to the Commission, 53% of green claims give vague, misleading or unfounded information. The same page describes consumer trust as extremely low. What the sources checked for this piece do not contain is a measure of how much weight shoppers actually give those claims when they choose. That gap shapes everything below, and we return to it at the end.

Green claims with vague, misleading or unfounded information (European Commission)
53%
Green labels with weak or non-existent verification (European Commission)
Half
EU sustainability labels counted by the European Commission
230
EU green energy labels, with vastly different transparency (European Commission)
100

What the data shows

The 53% figure is the most direct statement in these sources on how often green claims fail a basic test. The Commission attributes it to its own review of the market. The page does not, in the material we worked from, describe how the sample was drawn or what counted as vague. Treat it as the Commission's characterisation of the market rather than a measured index of trust, and say so if you quote it.

The second figure concerns verification. According to the Commission, half of green labels offer weak or non-existent verification. For a leader, this matters more than the raw count of labels. A label that a buyer cannot check gives the claim nothing to stand on, however careful the design or familiar the logo. A claim backed by a label that nobody can audit is still an unsupported claim.

Label volume is the third signal. The Commission cites 230 EU sustainability labels and 100 EU green energy labels, and says the energy labels differ widely in transparency. Its page also says consumers struggle to make sense of many environmental labels on goods and services. In our judgement, a shopper faced with that many marks will not read each one closely. The claim on the front of the pack therefore carries more weight than the evidence behind it, which is exactly where a company should be most careful.

The Commission defines greenwashing as companies giving a false impression of their environmental impacts or benefits. That definition covers more than outright falsehood. A true figure presented without its scope, or a real improvement presented without its baseline, can leave the same false impression. Many of the claims that erode trust are accurate sentences doing misleading work.

The Commission's page lists three example claim types and does not say whether any of them is misleading. The first describes a company's footprint as reduced by 20% since 2015. The second says emissions linked to a product were halved against 2020. The third promises a trustworthy sustainability label with guaranteed low environmental impact. Our judgement is that each has a weak point a reader can test. The first does not say which footprint or which boundary. The second does not say which emissions or how they were measured. The third promises a guarantee and leans on the word trustworthy to do the work that evidence should do. Those are the phrasings to review first.

A simple test works for all three. Ask for the baseline year, the boundary of what is counted, the measurement method and the place where the evidence sits. If any of the four has no clear answer, the claim is not ready to publish, whatever the design team thinks of it. The test does not tell you whether a claim is true. It tells you whether a sceptical reader could check it, which is the standard the Commission's own framing points toward.

Three figures from the European Commission

Shares and counts as the Commission's green claims page gives them. The page does not explain the method behind the first figure.

Green claims giving vague, misleading or unfounded information
53%
EU sustainability labels counted
230
EU green energy labels, with vastly different transparency
100

Source: European Commission

What it means for a leader

Start with the claims, not the campaign. List every environmental, social or circularity claim your products carry, wherever it appears: on pack, on the website, in tenders and in sales decks. For each one, write the evidence in a single line beside it. If the line cannot be written, the claim is not ready. This register is also the document that tells you which claims to retire first when the evidence turns out to be thinner than the marketing.

Directive (EU) 2024/825 was adopted on 28 February 2024 and published in the Official Journal on 6 March 2024, according to EUR-Lex. It amends Directives 2005/29/EC and 2011/83/EU. EUR-Lex says the directive names early obsolescence of goods, misleading environmental claims, misleading social information and non-transparent or non-credible sustainability labels as practices to tackle. It adds environmental, social and circularity aspects to Article 6(1) of Directive 2005/29/EC, to be assessed case by case, and it adds some practices to Annex I, where they are banned outright.

The social dimension is easy to overlook. EUR-Lex gives working conditions, adequate wages, social protection and social dialogue as examples of social claims. A claim about the people who made a product needs the same evidence as a claim about its carbon. Teams that have built rigorous carbon files often have nothing comparable for labour, and that gap is where a reader is most likely to find a contradiction.

The directive also covers durability, reparability and recyclability. According to EUR-Lex, consumers must not be misled about these characteristics through the overall presentation of a product. Presentation counts as well as wording. A product can be shown as durable through its imagery, its packaging and its spare-parts messaging without a single false sentence. Review the whole page or pack as a reader would, not only the claim text.

The Commission's green claims page says the Circular Economy Action Plan asks companies to substantiate their environmental claims using science-based, verifiable methods. That is the same standard the register above asks you to meet. A company that keeps its evidence in one place, dated and named, can answer that request in days. A company that reconstructs its evidence after a complaint takes months.

The Commission's page also describes a Green Claims Directive proposal adopted in March 2023, which it says complements a consumer-empowerment proposal. Its stated aim is reliable, comparable and verifiable environmental information on products. The sources checked for this piece do not say how far that proposal has progressed, so check its status before planning around it. Do not treat a proposal as settled law because it is named on a Commission page.

UK businesses sit under a different set of rules. GOV.UK's green claims code is UK guidance rather than EU law. It is written for businesses on existing consumer-law duties, and it says it is not legal advice. It covers the areas the Competition and Markets Authority sees as most likely relevant to enforcement. GOV.UK's separate advice on marketing green heating and insulation stresses that responsibility runs across the supply chain, so a retailer or installer cannot hand the claim to its supplier and step away from it.

Whether a specific claim breaches the law in a given market is a question for a lawyer in that market. The sources here do not answer it, and no general guide can stand in for that advice.

Limits of the data

The central question of this piece is not answered by the sources we used. None of them gives an EU consumer survey measure of how much weight shoppers give green claims. The Commission's green claims page does not cite any EU consumer survey results on trust. The 53% and half figures describe claims and labels, not shopper behaviour, and neither comes with a stated method. The count of labels is also not a count of the labels people actually see or buy. The page does not say whether its three example claims are misleading. Before publishing anything that says what European consumers believe, find the Commission's Eurobarometer work or an equivalent survey, and cite its date, sample and method.

Until that evidence is in hand, the sensible course is the one the figures already support. Assume that a large share of green claims will be read as weak, and assume that a label nobody can verify will be read as no label at all. Put one named owner on the claim register, review it each quarter with finance and legal in the room, and take any claim that cannot pass the four-part test off the packaging until the evidence is written down. That costs little. Being wrong in public costs a great deal more.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.