Allocating senior leadership time across business units
Three tests, applied unit by unit, show a board where its senior people should spend their hours, which units need fewer of them, and when a venture should be stopped.

Most groups with more than one business spread their senior people by habit. The chief executive spends Thursdays with whichever unit raised a problem last, while a quiet unit holding the largest exposure gets a monthly call. In our experience, attention follows noise rather than consequence. A framework will not remove the noise, but it gives the board a shared set of questions to answer before anyone books a diary slot. What follows uses three tests: strategic value, performance trend and management maturity.
A caveat first, and it matters more than anything else here. None of the sources we checked defines strategic value, performance trend or management maturity, and none sets a method for dividing senior leadership time across business units. The IFRS 8 standard on operating segments, issued by the International Accounting Standards Board in November 2006, requires listed entities, meaning those with publicly traded debt or equity, to give information that helps users judge their separate business activities and the economic settings they operate in, according to the IFRS Foundation. That gives you raw segment data. It does not tell you how to weigh it. The three tests below are our judgement, offered as a working model to adjust rather than a published standard.
Chapter one: 1. Strategic value
Begin by asking what the group would lose if the unit stopped, beyond the revenue line it reports. Some units earn well and stand alone. Others hold a customer relationship, a plant, a licence or a team that other units rely on. Those units deserve senior time even when their margins look unremarkable, because their value sits in what they make possible elsewhere.
A sensible test has three parts. Identify which other units buy from this one, sell to it or share its customers. Identify which capability would take years to rebuild if the unit closed. Identify which decision about the unit would be hardest to reverse. Score each unit roughly on those answers and write the reasons beside the score. The scores matter less than the written reasons, because reasons give the board something to argue about other than instinct.
Segment disclosure helps with the first part. IFRS 8 also covers disclosures on products and services, geographic areas and major customers, the IFRS Foundation notes. If two units report to the same large customer or sell into the same region, the standard's categories will show the overlap. Test whether one unit's problem is really another unit's exposure before deciding which one deserves the diary.
Units can score high on value and low on maturity, and that combination deserves the most senior time of all. A valuable unit with a weak team is where attention earns the most, and it is also where attention is most often withheld, because the unit looks quiet in the monthly pack. Flag those units explicitly. A quiet unit that the group cannot function without is a decision the board has not yet made.
Chapter two: 2. Performance trend
A good quarter is a fact about timing. Three or more years of a consistent measure is a trend. Pick one measure for each unit that the unit can be held to, and apply the same definition in every period. Changing the definition partway through is a common way for a weak trend to look strong on paper, and boards rarely notice because the chart appears clean.
No source in our set gives a metric for performance trend by business unit beyond the segment disclosures in IFRS 8, so the measure is yours to choose, and you should say why you chose it. A useful test is whether someone outside the unit could recalculate the figure from the group's own reporting. If nobody can, the trend cannot be checked. A figure nobody can check is a weak basis for moving senior people.
Read the direction and the speed separately. Flat revenue with rising margin is a different problem from rising revenue with falling margin, and a blended score hides the difference. Give the board both lines for each unit, and ask the unit's leader which of the two their own plan expects to change first.
Chapter three: 3. Management maturity
This pillar measures how much senior time a unit needs in order to function, which is a different matter from how much it deserves. A unit with a finance lead who reports numbers unprompted, a written plan that survived one bad year and a named successor can be reviewed monthly. A unit without those needs closer attention. That attention should aim at building the missing pieces, not at doing the work for the team.
Put four questions to each unit's leader. Establish when they last missed a forecast by more than they had said they might, and what changed afterwards. Establish who could run the unit for six months if the leader were unavailable. Establish which decisions the leader may take alone, and whether that is written down. Establish what the leader reports to the group without being asked. Answers that come quickly and with evidence point to maturity. Answers that need a week to assemble point the other way.
For units with operations abroad, add a compliance check. The DOJ and SEC's guide to the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, in its second edition, was first released in November 2012 and updated in July 2020, according to the Justice Department's FCPA guidance page. The guide sets out what the agencies regard as the features of a working corporate compliance programme. It also treats the existence of such a programme as a factor in enforcement decisions. Voluntary self-disclosure, full cooperation and timely remediation are listed as factors the agencies weigh in charging decisions. Ask whether each foreign unit's programme would meet that description, and who in the group would know if it did not.
The same guide also covers successor liability in mergers and acquisitions. Maturity is therefore a question for units you bought as well as units you built. A business acquired recently may carry a compliance gap into the group, and the first review after completion should check it. Put that question to counsel as well as to the integration team. Legal exposure is a matter for lawyers, not for a scorecard.
Portfolio attention check
Answer every question for every business unit. A no is a reason to move senior time, or to explain in writing why the time stays where it is.
- Have we written down the reason each unit receives senior time?
- Can someone outside the unit recalculate its trend figure from group reporting?
- Has the trend been measured with the same definition for at least three periods?
- Does each unit have a named successor who could run it for six months?
- Can the unit's leader list, in writing, the decisions they may take alone?
- For units abroad, does the compliance programme meet the DOJ hallmarks?
- Does every unit still run as a venture have a written stop condition?
- Has the board recorded which unit it is protecting, and at whose cost?
Outgrace checklist
Where it breaks
The framework fails in three predictable ways. The first is that scores get produced and then ignored, because the diaries were already full. Put the review on a fixed cycle, at least twice a year, with a rule that a unit moves up or down only when its written reasons change. Otherwise the map becomes decoration in the board pack, and senior time goes where it always went.
The second is the unit that is really a venture. NBER Working Paper 34755, 'Learning to Quit?', by Bailey, Fehder, Floyd, Hochberg and Lee, reports a multi-year, multi-site randomised field experiment with innovation-driven entrepreneurs. Its subject is founders rather than corporate units, but its framing is useful here. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, entrepreneurship training may help founders recognise when to stop investing time and resources in a venture. The paper's title frames the question as whether training can help founders learn when to quit. For any unit still in venture mode, write the stop condition before the next budget is approved, not after the spending has started.
The third is the pull of the portfolio itself. Madison Condon's article 'Externalities and the Common Owner', published in 95 Washington Law Review 1 in 2020, is about common ownership and externalities. The article's title points to that subject; we use it only as an analogy. A group can drift the same way. It protects one unit because that unit shields another, or it starves a unit for the good of the whole, and nobody writes the trade-off down. Record it in the board minute, together with the unit that pays for it.
On Monday, pull the segment figures for the last three years for each unit, and write one strategic value note and four maturity answers beside each. Add a stop condition for any venture still inside the group, and a compliance question for any unit operating abroad. Put the map on the next board agenda as a draft, with its reasons visible. Keep the first version rough. A map reviewed every six months will teach the board more than a polished one produced once and then left alone.