Outgrace, home
OperationsQ&A primer

What a warehouse lease's dilapidation clause commits you to

The questions to put to your lawyer and surveyor before signing, and the accounting and rates facts that sit alongside the clause. Not legal advice.

This primer is for finance leads, directors and operations heads who are signing, renewing or inheriting a warehouse lease. The one thing to remember is that the dilapidation clause is a cost you accept at the start and pay, in some form, at the end. Most of the money is decided before anyone moves in: in the definitions, in the record of the building's condition, and in the timing of the bill. Our research found no primary source on dilapidation or reinstatement clauses, so what follows is practical judgement and questions to put to advisers, not a statement of how a court would read your lease. The facts we cite come from the IFRS Foundation's IFRS 16 page, GOV.UK's business rates guidance and the Law Commission's website. This is not legal advice. Your lease, a property lawyer and an accountant decide what applies to you.

What is a dilapidation clause, in plain terms?

In our experience, it is the part of a lease that makes the tenant responsible for the state of the building when the lease comes to an end. The clause usually compares the building's condition at exit with a standard set out in the lease or in a schedule. The exact wording varies from lease to lease, so read your own document rather than a summary of it. Check whether the clause covers repair, decoration, removal of fixtures and making good after alterations, because each of those can carry a separate cost.

Is a dilapidation clause the same as a reinstatement clause?

The two are often used together, and sometimes one is used in place of the other. A reinstatement clause, in our experience, is more often about returning the building to an earlier layout or specification after you have altered it. Do not assume the words mean the same thing in your lease. The definitions section decides what each term requires, and it is the first place a lawyer will look.

When does the bill actually fall due?

In many leases the claim arrives at or after the end of the term, when the landlord inspects the building and the tenant has often already moved out. Some leases allow the landlord to start works before the lease ends, and some allow the tenant to carry out works first. The timing matters because a cost that lands eighteen months after you leave is harder to forecast and harder to dispute. Ask when the claim can be made and whether there is a time limit on it.

Why does the condition record matter so much?

The clause measures the building against a standard, and that standard is usually the building's condition at the start, or the state the lease describes. If there is no written record of that condition, the gap tends to be argued against the tenant. A sensible test is whether you could show, with dated photographs and a signed surveyor's report, what the warehouse looked like on the day you took it. If you could not, treat the schedule of condition as the most important document you negotiate.

How does the dilapidation cost show up in the accounts?

The IFRS 16 page from the IFRS Foundation says the standard requires a lessee to recognise a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for leases with a term over 12 months, unless the underlying asset is of low value. The same page says the standard does not address lease-end obligations or dilapidations. So IFRS 16 tells you how to account for the lease payments, but it does not tell you how to measure the bill at the end. Ask your auditor and accounting adviser how a lease-end cost would be estimated and whether it should be recognised before the end of the term.

Does IFRS 16 tell me how big the bill will be?

No. The standard sets out recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure for leases, with the stated objective of giving users information on the amount, timing and uncertainty of lease cash flows. Those are the right questions to ask of any lease-end cost, but the standard does not supply the number. The number comes from the lease terms, the condition of the building and the contractors' prices, so the estimate is a judgement your finance team has to document.

Do business rates change the picture?

They are a separate cost, but they belong on the same list. GOV.UK says business rates are charged on most non-domestic properties, and you will probably pay if you use a building, or part of one, for non-domestic purposes. The local council sends the bill each February or March, and it covers the following tax year. Rates run for as long as you occupy the building, so they should be modelled through the lease term, not only at signing.

Are there reliefs I should check for?

GOV.UK says some relief is available from the local council. Some relief is given automatically, while other relief may need applying for. Do not assume either way. Ask the council which reliefs could apply to your premises and what the deadline is for any application, and record the answer in the file. If you are unsure whether rates or another charge applies to a particular part of the site, GOV.UK advises contacting the VO.

Could the law change under me?

The Law Commission describes itself as an independent body, created in 1965, which keeps the law of England and Wales under review and recommends reform. Its website lists current projects on transport accessibility for disabled people, contempt of court and disabled children's social care. None of those concern leases or dilapidations. That tells you no reform project on this subject is listed there, not that the law is settled for ever. A lawyer should confirm the position for the lease you are about to sign.

Who should review the clause before I sign?

A property lawyer should read the definitions, the repair and reinstatement obligations, the schedule of condition, the timing of claims and any cap or time limit. A building surveyor should record the condition of the building before you take possession. An accountant should advise on how the lease-end cost is treated in your accounts. This is a matter for a lawyer, and the cost of a careful review is small against the cost of a dispute at the end of the term.

What should I ask the landlord for?

Ask for the schedule of condition to be attached to the lease and agreed before signing. Ask which words the clause uses for the state the building must be left in, and whether the lease sets out the works that count. Ask whether you may carry out repair works before the end of the term, who chooses the contractor, and whether the landlord will accept a financial settlement in place of works. Each request is a question, and the answers should be in writing.

Can the clause be negotiated before signing?

In our experience, the landlord's draft is a starting point rather than a final offer, although that varies with the market and the size of the tenant. The terms that most often move are the condition baseline, the scope of the works and the timing of the claim. Negotiating those three terms usually does more for the final cost than arguing about the headline rent. Your lawyer should tell you which points are worth pressing for your particular lease.

What happens if we assign or sublet the lease?

The obligations in a lease can follow the tenant and sometimes continue after the tenant has passed the lease on. Check the assignment and subletting clauses, the guarantor arrangements, and who remains liable after a transfer. The answer depends on the wording of your lease, so this is a question for a property lawyer before any transfer is agreed. Do not treat a sublet as ending your exposure until the lawyer confirms it.

The mistake behind most of these

Most of the trouble with dilapidation clauses starts with treating them as boilerplate. A team agrees the rent, the term and the break options, signs the lease on those terms, and leaves the clause to the lawyers. The cost then appears in the last year of the lease, when the options are few and the building has been used hard for a decade. The same mistake shows up in the accounts. Finance records the lease under the accounting standard, sees the payments modelled and assumes the end of the lease is covered. The IFRS 16 page says the standard does not address dilapidations, so that assumption is not safe. The fix is to bring the clause into the signing decision, with the same seriousness as the rent, and to ask the question that matters early: what will this building need to look like on the last day, and who will decide whether it does?

This week, pull the lease and find every place it mentions dilapidations, reinstatement, repair, decoration, alterations and the schedule of condition. Put those pages in front of your property lawyer with a short list of the questions in this primer, and ask for written answers. Book a building surveyor to record the condition of the warehouse, with dated photographs, before you take possession or before any renewal is signed. Ask your finance lead to estimate what a lease-end claim could cost on three assumptions: a light claim, a typical claim and a claim for a full reinstatement. Ask your auditor how that estimate should be treated in the accounts. Then ask the council about rates and any relief you may be able to claim. None of these steps is expensive. Each one is far cheaper than discovering the answer in the final quarter of the lease.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.