Outgrace
OutgraceThe Leadership Magazine, home

How an employee ownership trust works, and what it asks of leaders

The structure is set by Canadian rules that decide who votes and who is paid. What it does to culture is not shown by the research our sources contain.

Woman, work, office, whiteboard, meeting, girl
Photo: This_is_Engineering / Pixabay

A founder who wants the staff to own the company has to settle two questions before any share moves: who holds the shares, and for whose benefit. In Canada, one answer is an employee ownership trust, or EOT. It is a structure with strict rules, and those rules shape culture, because they decide who has a say, who is paid and what the trustees may not do. This explainer sets out how the structure works, what the official guidance says, and where our judgement begins.

How it works

The structure rests on one idea. A trust holds shares of a corporation for the benefit of its employees, and the employees acquire the business without paying directly for the shares. The Canada Revenue Agency's guidance describes the arrangement in those terms, and the quotation at the end of this piece is taken from that page. The trust is the legal holder. The employees are the people the trust exists to serve.

Not every business can use the structure. The guidance defines a qualifying business, or QB, as a corporation controlled by a trust. The transaction that puts it there is a qualifying business transfer, or QBT. In a QBT the seller disposes of shares either to a trust or to a CCPC that the trust controls and wholly owns. The guidance outlines both terms, but the full conditions do not appear in the extract we reviewed. Anyone planning a deal around them should check the complete text first.

Two further tests keep the trust to its purpose. First, all or substantially all of the trust's property must be shares of qualifying businesses it controls. The guidance says this generally means 90% or more by fair market value. Second, the trust must be irrevocable at all times, so the arrangement cannot be reversed at will once it is in place. Leaders should assume the rules outlast the transaction, and should review the asset mix every year rather than only when a sale is on the table.

Governance is where ownership becomes a working arrangement. Each current employee beneficiary has one equal vote in the trust's affairs. The vote is the same for a long-serving manager and a recent hire. Listed transactions or events must be approved by more than 50% of current employee beneficiaries before they occur. The list of those transactions and events is missing from the extract we reviewed, so the board should obtain the full text before it writes its own approval rules.

The trustees carry the duty that matters most day to day. They must not act for one beneficiary group to prejudice another. The guidance sets income and capital interests the same way for current employees and, where applicable, for former employees. A trustee who tilts decisions toward one group at the expense of another is acting against the rule the guidance states, whatever the intention behind the decision.

Money follows the distribution formula, and the formula is where most of the argument will happen. Income and capital may be divided differently. Current and former employees may be treated differently. Each formula must use at least one listed factor, and the allocation must apply only the listed criteria, applied in a reasonable and equitable way. No other criteria are allowed. Where current and former employees both benefit, up to four distribution formulas may be used.

Two numerical rules decide how much each person receives. The first is a salary cap. Pay counted toward an allocation is capped at twice the highest personal income tax bracket, per calendar year, and the cap is prorated for partial years. The guidance's second example shows the effect. A person who earned $1m has $965,000 eligible after the cap, which gives a 12.063% share, or $241,250 of a $2m dividend paid at the end of Year 3. That dividend was based only on pay from July of Year 1 to June of Year 3.

The second rule is the weighting. In the guidance's first example, a qualifying business that began in Year 1 was bought by an EOT in Year 4, and a $2m dividend was distributed in Year 9. The formula weights seniority at 50% and five-year pay at 50%. An employee with nine years' service and $300,000 pay across Years 4 to 8 receives a 0.215% share, which comes to $4,300. The pool behind that share is 5,000 service-years and $120m of pay.

Generally required share of trust property, by fair market value; Canada Revenue Agency
90%
More than 50% of current employee beneficiaries must approve listed events; Canada Revenue
50%
Maximum distribution formulas where both current and former employees benefit; Canada Reve
Four
Eligible pool in the guidance's second worked example, after the salary cap; Canada Revenu
$8m

Who it affects

According to the guidance, the new EOT rules apply to transactions after 31 December 2023, under Budget 2023. The guidance says the rules define the qualifying conditions for an EOT and ease its set-up. The people affected are Canadian corporations controlled by employee ownership trusts, their current and former employees, and business owners planning succession. The sources we reviewed name no other sectors or regions, so nothing here is a statement about employee ownership trusts elsewhere.

Each group has a different stake. For the company, the trust becomes the controlling holder, and the board must work within its approval rules. For employees, the questions are what they receive and when. For a retiring owner, the guidance presents the EOT as an additional option for succession planning. That wording matters. It places the structure as one route among several, not as a default. A leader who adopts it without comparing the alternatives has skipped the most useful part of the decision.

What leaders get wrong

The culture question is the one leaders most want answered, and the one our sources cannot answer. The extracts we reviewed from the National Bureau of Economic Research and the Pew Research Center contain nothing on employee ownership, governance or company culture. No source we were given covers behaviour or commitment in employee-owned firms. What the structure does give, on the guidance's own terms, is a formal voice: one equal vote for each current employee beneficiary on trust affairs. Whether that voice changes how people behave at work is an open question. Treat it as a hypothesis to test, not a result to promise.

  • Treating the EOT as a sale and stopping there. The trust must be irrevocable at all times, so the governance and distribution rules keep running after the deal closes.
  • Writing the distribution formula after the numbers are known. Each formula must use at least one listed factor, and the allocation may apply only the listed criteria.
  • Forgetting that the salary cap is prorated for partial years, which changes the figures for anyone who joined or left mid-year.
  • Reading the extract as the whole rulebook. The beneficiary conditions, the list of events that need approval and the full qualifying business conditions are missing from it, so any decision built on the extract is provisional.
  • Promising staff a change in commitment. Nothing in the sources we reviewed supports that promise.

What to do about it

Start with the vote and the formula, not the share price. Before any transaction, ask three questions. Which events need the approval of more than half of current employee beneficiaries? Who counts as a beneficiary under the listed conditions? What weights does the distribution formula give to seniority and to pay? Write the answers down in plain language for staff. In our experience, a formula that people cannot explain causes more friction than a formula that is merely complicated, whatever the law says.

Then take those questions to a tax adviser and a lawyer. The guidance says the EOT is a taxable trust that generally follows the rules for other personal trusts, and the extract cuts off before the rule on undistributed income. Qualifying conditions, trustee duties and the approval list all need professional confirmation before a board relies on them. Ask the adviser to show you the full guidance, the clauses of the trust deed and the formula in writing, and to explain how each rule would apply to your own staff.

An EOT is a form of employee ownership where a trust holds shares of a corporation for the benefit of the corporation's employees.

Canada Revenue Agency, canada.ca

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.