Outgrace
OutgraceThe Leadership Magazine, home
Capital & FinanceHow-to guide

How to write a dividend policy a family group can defend

A written payout rule, a cash floor and a documented route for exceptions stop the annual argument from becoming a fight over who needs the money.

A loving family shares a group hug in their modern kitchen, showcasing warmth and togetherness.
Photo: MART PRODUCTION / Pexels

Most family shareholder groups argue about the dividend once a year, in the same room, with the same people, and they lose the argument each time because nobody wrote the rule down. The business needs cash to fund what it plans to do. Some members need cash to live. Without a written rule, each side argues from its own need, and the chair settles the matter by mood. This guide sets out how to write a payout rule the family can defend to itself, and how to record exceptions so that they do not quietly become the rule. It draws on the governance principles in the two law-firm memos reposted on the Harvard Law School Forum, and it is a matter of judgement rather than a summary of distribution law, which varies by jurisdiction and by each company's own documents.

Before you start

Two things must be true before anyone drafts a number. First, the group must agree what the company is trying to do over the next three to five years. A rule cannot balance reinvestment against liquidity while the reinvestment plan is still a list of wishes. Second, one person must own the cash numbers. In our experience the finance lead prepares the forecast, and the board does not accept a payout proposal that has not been run through it. Gather four things before the first meeting:

  • A current capital plan listing each project that needs cash, ranked by the date the money is due.
  • A cash forecast covering at least the next two budget cycles, including a normal year and a poor one.
  • The articles of association and any shareholder agreement, read for restrictions on distributions and on share transfers.
  • A register of who holds which shares and of every request for cash from a member in the past three years.

Whether the company may pay a distribution at all depends on company law in its jurisdiction and on its own constitutional documents. That question belongs to a company lawyer, and the accountant should confirm which accounts the test is applied to. Put both questions to them before the policy goes near the family. If the company is a UK limited company, its registered information is available to the public through Companies House, which the government describes as the body that registers company information for public access. Assume that the family's rules, and the decisions taken under them, may one day be read by people outside the family, and draft them accordingly.

  1. Step 1

    Write the purpose in one sentence

    State what the distribution is for. A sound purpose names both the company's need and the family's expectation, for example: keep the business funded for its agreed plan, and give shareholders a return they can plan around. Groups that skip this step end up with two policies in one document, one for the business and one for the family, and they contradict each other in the first hard year. What usually goes wrong is a purpose written as a slogan, such as fair to everyone, which cannot decide a s

  2. Step 2

    Set the reinvestment floor

    Agree the cash the business keeps before any dividend is considered. It should equal the capital plan for the next cycle plus a buffer for a bad year, and the finance lead should state the buffer in currency rather than as a share of profit. The floor is the rule's most important line, because it is the one that protects projects already approved. What usually goes wrong is that the floor is set at the level the family would like to receive, and the business then borrows to fund a project it had

  3. Step 3

    Choose one payout basis

    Pick a single measure and define it on one page: a share of distributable profit, a fixed amount per share, or a payment linked to a cash test. Each fails in a different way. A percentage of a volatile profit produces a volatile dividend, which a family that relies on the money will resent. A fixed amount can exceed what the business can afford in a weak year. The definitions matter more than the choice, so have counsel and the accountant write them. What usually goes wrong is that the group nam

  4. Step 4

    Separate surplus from member liquidity

    Many family groups use one dividend to answer two questions: what the business can spare, and what individual members need. Keep them apart. The dividend answers the first question. The second question needs its own route, such as a buy-back or a transfer of shares to another family member under the shareholder agreement, and counsel should confirm which routes the constitution allows. What usually goes wrong is that the company pays out more than it can spare to meet one member's need, and the

  5. Step 5

    Write the exception procedure

    Name who may approve a departure from the rule, the threshold that sends a request to the full board, and what the paper must contain: the reason, the effect on the reinvestment floor, and the date the exception will be reviewed. Require the decision and the vote to be minuted. What usually goes wrong is that exceptions are agreed in a conversation between the chair and the largest shareholder, and no one can later explain why the rule applied to some members and not others.

  6. Step 6

    Set a review date and a sunset

    Fix an annual review with a set date, and add triggers for an early review, such as a capital project above an agreed size, a change in control, or a loss in the forecast. The Cravath memo, reposted on the Harvard forum, describes time-based or event-based sunset provisions in founder-control structures. The same logic can apply to a payout rule, by analogy: the rule expires unless the board renews it. What usually goes wrong is that the policy is reopened only when someone is angry.

  7. Step 7

    Test voting against economics

    The Wachtell Lipton memo, also reposted on the Harvard forum, states the principle that economic ownership and voting power should travel together. Apply it by analogy to a family group whose share classes differ. If members with the most votes receive the largest share of distributions, or the reverse, write down why, and record whether the group accepts that effect. What usually goes wrong is that share classes created for control reasons end up deciding dividends, and nobody checks the effect

  8. Step 8

    Adopt it as a board decision

    Draft the policy as a board paper, with the rule, the floor, the exception procedure and the review date on the first page. Have counsel check it against the constitution and any shareholder agreement before the family votes, and have the board adopt it formally so that it has standing when a dividend is paid. What usually goes wrong is that the family approves the policy as a principle, the board never adopts it, and the rule has no formal status when the first payment is made.

What usually goes wrong

Most failed policies fail at the same point: the rule was written to settle a single argument rather than to govern a series of decisions. A family agrees a payout level in a good year and then cannot revise it when the forecast turns. The rule becomes a promise, and a promise that cannot bend is quietly ignored. The remedy is to write the floor, the review date and the exception route into the rule itself, so that changing it is an ordinary act of governance and not a breach.

The second failure is informal exceptions. A member who needs cash asks the chair, the chair agrees, and the payment is made before anyone records the reason. Each exception looks small. Together they replace the policy with a set of private favours, and the members who did not ask begin to feel the rule is for others. Every exception should pass through the same written procedure, however urgent the request, and the minutes should show that the procedure was followed.

Should we pay a fixed amount or a share of profit?

Neither is right in itself. A share of profit moves with the business, which protects the company in a bad year but makes the family's income unpredictable. A fixed amount gives members something to plan around but can strain cash in a weak year. Many groups choose the basis after the cash floor is agreed, because the floor decides how much volatility the business can absorb.

Who should decide the dividend, the board or the family?

That depends on the company's constitution and on company law in its jurisdiction, so it is a question for company counsel rather than for this guide. Whatever the answer, the group should be clear about the division of roles, and the policy should say which body approves an ordinary payment and which approves an exception.

What do we do when a member urgently needs cash?

Treat the request as a liquidity question and send it down the separate route, not through the dividend. The shareholder agreement may already provide a buy-back or a transfer mechanism, and counsel should confirm what is available and at what cost to the company. The exception procedure applies even when the need is pressing, because urgency is the most common reason rules are bent.

Does a public register affect our dividend decisions?

If the company is a UK limited company, its filings are on the Companies House register, which the government says is available for public access. Which documents must be filed, and whether a particular dividend decision is among them, is a question for your accountant or company lawyer. Draft the policy on the assumption that outsiders may read it.

This week, do three things. Ask the finance lead for a cash forecast covering two budget cycles, with a normal year and a poor one. Ask company counsel three written questions: what the constitution and shareholder agreement allow on distributions and transfers, who may approve a payment, and what the company must file. Then put a single page on the next board agenda with the purpose, the reinvestment floor and the proposed exception procedure, and invite the family to comment on that page rather than on a number. A group that agrees the floor before it argues about the payout will have a policy it can defend when the year turns difficult.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.