Outgrace
OutgraceThe Leadership Magazine, home

How listing rules and IAS 24 define related-party deals

Accounting rules catch a deal with an insider even when no money changes hands. The UK listing text that says who must approve one needs checking before any board relies on it.

A deal with an insider is rarely the one a board worries about. It is the office lease signed by a director's family company, or the consultancy fee paid to a former chief executive, which nobody flagged because the price looked fair. The accounting standard IAS 24 treats a transfer of resources, services or obligations between a company and a related party as a related party transaction. Price does not decide the question. The UK listing regime has separate rules on approving such deals, and the two sets of rules answer different questions.

How it works

IAS 24 sits inside the financial statements. The IFRS website states the standard's aim: that financial statements disclose what may have affected a company's financial position and profit through related parties and their transactions. That is a disclosure duty. It tells readers what happened. On its own, it does not say who must give permission beforehand. The standard also has to be read as a whole. Who counts as a related party is defined in its own paragraphs, and a board should work from those paragraphs rather than from anyone's summary, including this one.

Two things trigger the disclosure duty, according to the IFRS page. The first is the transaction. The standard defines it as any transfer of resources, services or obligations between the entity and a related party, and it counts even when no price is charged. The second is the period. Where related party transactions occur in a period, the company must disclose the nature of the relationship, the transaction and balance details, including commitments. A free office, a waived fee or a loan at no charge all fall inside the first limb. The question for a finance team is therefore whether something passed, not whether the price was fair.

The standard also asks for key management personnel compensation, disclosed in total and by category. For a board, that line places the executive team's pay in one part of the accounts, where a reader can compare it with the rest of the business. It is a disclosure, not an approval, and boards sometimes confuse the two when they review the remuneration pack.

The standard is old, and its history explains some of its shape. The International Accounting Standards Committee issued it in July 1984. The International Accounting Standards Board adopted it in April 2001 and revised it in December 2003. The November 2009 revision simplified the related party definition and gave certain government-related entities an exemption from some disclosures. The IFRS page lists later consequential amendments: changes tied to IFRS 10, 11 and 12 in May 2011, IAS 19 in June 2011, investment entities in October 2012, Annual Improvements 2010–2012 in December 2013, and IFRS 18 in April 2024. A reader who finds an older copy of the standard should check which version applies to the period in question.

Threshold for prior approval of a related party supply, academy trusts, per GOV.UK
£40,000
Date the FCA's overhauled listing rules applied from, per the FCA press release
29 July 2024
Year IAS 24 was revised to simplify the related party definition, per IFRS
2009

The UK listing regime works differently, and it has changed recently. According to the FCA's press release, the overhaul of the listing rules applied from 29 July 2024, and the regulator called it the biggest listing regime change in over three decades. The release says the new rules remove shareholder votes on related party transactions and on significant transactions. Shareholder approval is still needed for reverse takeovers and for taking shares off an exchange. A board that remembers the old vote requirement needs to update its approval map, because the FCA's own summary says the vote has gone.

What the release does not give is the rule text. None of the FCA sources we reviewed reproduces the listing rule that defines a related party transaction, or says who must approve one where approval is still required. The FCA's historic Listing Rules are available for earlier periods. The rules from 1966 to January 2000 can be obtained free on CD-ROM, but the FCA notes that they are FSA documents rather than its own. The Listing Rules from June 2005 onwards sit in the FCA Handbook, and can be chosen by date. A board that needs the current definition should read the current Handbook directly, not a summary of it, and not a comparison with an earlier version.

Until the text is checked, a workable test has two questions. The first is whether IAS 24 treats the deal as a related party transaction. If it does, it must be disclosed in the financial statements whatever its price. The second is whether the current listing rulebook still requires any approval for that kind of deal, and if so, which body gives it. Since the 2024 change removed votes on related party transactions, the second question is no longer answered by the shareholder meeting calendar. It is answered by the rulebook, and the answer should be written into the board's approval policy with a reference to the rule.

Who it affects

Four groups meet these rules in practice. Listed companies on UK markets sit under the FCA regime for approvals, and must read the rulebook for the current position. Reporting entities that apply IAS 24 carry the disclosure duty in their financial statements, whether or not they are listed. Certain government-related entities get an exemption from some of the standard's disclosures, so their finance teams need to check which parts still apply. Key management personnel are the individuals whose compensation the standard asks companies to disclose, in total and by category.

Academy trusts in England are a separate case and a useful contrast. They fall under a regime run by the Department for Education, not the FCA. From 1 October 2024, according to GOV.UK guidance, trusts report or seek approval for related party transactions with the DfE, a duty that previously sat with the ESFA. The guidance says a trust must report an intended new related party transaction before confirming it, and renewals count. Income transactions with related parties need no report. Salaries paid through the trust payroll under an employment contract are outside the reporting scope. Every related party transaction, whatever its value, must still be declared in the annual financial statements under the Academies Accounts Direction.

Prior approval is the sharp edge of that regime. For a supply of goods or services by a related party over £40,000, the guidance requires prior approval, for transactions starting on or after 1 September 2023 and tied to the financial year ending 31 August. The £40,000 test applies to single transactions with the same supplier. Values are not added together by supplier. Two further limits matter. The approval concession does not extend to subsidiaries of a related party. And novel, contentious or repercussive transactions need prior approval whatever their value. The guidance flags transactions involving the board chair or accounting officer as needing careful consideration under that test.

What leaders get wrong

  • Using price as the test. IAS 24 counts a transfer even when no price is charged, so a free arrangement with an insider is still a transaction to be disclosed.
  • Treating the 2024 change as the end of approvals. The FCA release removes shareholder votes on related party transactions, but it keeps approval for reverse takeovers and for taking shares off an exchange. Any other approval has to be found in the rule text.
  • Reporting late. In the academy regime, GOV.UK says retrospective reporting is a breach of the Academy trust handbook, and the accounting officer must report any breach in the statement on regularity, propriety and compliance.
  • Assuming one approval covers everything. A single request can cover a series of transactions with the same supplier, but only if the detail for each transaction is given.
  • Forgetting the records. Records of all related party transactions must be kept even where no approval is needed.
  • Extending the concession to subsidiaries. The DfE guidance says the approval concession does not reach subsidiaries of a related party.

What to do about it

Start with a register, not a transaction. Ask management to list every person and company that the IAS 24 definition captures, and keep the list current as board members, senior managers and owners change. The register is the only reliable way to notice that a supplier is a related party before the invoice arrives. Most of the failures in the academy guidance, from missed approvals to late reports, begin with a supplier nobody had mapped.

Then run each insider deal through the disclosure question first, including the free and the small ones. In our experience, disclosure is the duty most likely to be missed, because it is triggered by the fact of a transfer rather than by its size. Approval is a second question and should be answered from the current rulebook, not from memory or from last year's board paper.

For a listed company, ask the company secretary or external counsel to confirm from the current FCA Handbook whether any approval remains for the deal in question, and who gives it. A board that approves a related party deal on the strength of a summary has not checked the rule. This is a matter for a lawyer, and the rule text is the one thing this article cannot provide.

For an academy trust, the approval question is more mechanical, and the sharp edges sit in the guidance. Check the £40,000 single-transaction test against each supplier. Check every novel, contentious or repercussive case regardless of value. Make sure the chair or the accounting officer has been considered under that test before anything is signed. Record the approval request, its detail and its outcome, and keep a record of every related party transaction, including those that need no approval. A trust that does this has little to explain to the accounting officer's statement at year end, and the trust's own accounts will show the same discipline.

Whatever the regime, the board should see the register and the approval log in the same pack. An insider deal that appears in one and not the other is the first thing an auditor, regulator or journalist will look for, and the simplest way to avoid that is to keep the two documents identical in scope.

The new rules remove the need for votes on significant or related party transactions and offer flexibility around enhanced voting rights.

FCA press release, on the 2024 overhaul of the listing rules, fca.org.uk

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.