Outgrace, home

Questions boards should ask before relying on D&O cover

A D&O policy protects only what its wording says it protects. These are the questions to put to the broker, counsel and the finance lead before anyone relies on the cover.

Most boards assume that their directors' and officers' cover will respond when they need it. That assumption is the thing to test. This primer sets out the questions a chair, founder or audit committee member should put before relying on the cover, and the places where readers most often misread what they have been given. It is not a summary of any policy. The signed policy document is the only text that governs the company's position, and the questions below tell you where to look in it. Where a question depends on a legal reading, the answer belongs to counsel, and we say so each time.

Is the certificate or the broker's summary enough to rely on?

No. A certificate shows that a policy exists and names the insurer and the limit. It does not tell you what the policy covers, what it excludes or what the company must do to keep the cover. In our experience, boards that rely on the summary discover the gap only after a claim has been made. Ask for the full wording of every policy layer, including any endorsements added after the original placement.

Who should read the policy, and in what order?

Counsel should read it, and the finance lead and the company secretary should read it alongside counsel. Start with the declarations page, which shows the limits, the retention and the period covered. Then read the definitions, because many disputes turn on how a defined term is read. The exclusions and the conditions come after that. Reading in this order stops the reader from treating the headline limit as the whole answer.

Why do the definitions matter more than the headline terms?

A definition sets the meaning of the words the rest of the policy depends on. A phrase such as who counts as an insured person, or what counts as a claim, can decide whether an event falls inside the cover at all. Readers tend to skim these pages because they look like preamble. A sensible test is to take three real scenarios from the company's last two years and ask counsel to say, using only the definitions, whether each would be covered.

What is an exclusion, and how should a board read one?

An exclusion is a stated category of loss or conduct that the policy does not cover. Boards often read exclusions as a list of rare events, and then discover that one of them describes a common situation in their business. Read each exclusion against the company's own operations and its risk register. Where an exclusion touches a risk the board already rates as material, minute that link and ask the broker to explain it in writing.

What does a notice condition require of the company?

A notice condition sets out what the company must tell the insurer, how it must tell them, and within what period. It is a condition of the cover, not a courtesy, so a late or incomplete notice can put the cover at risk even where the claim itself is within the policy. Write down who is responsible for giving notice, the route they must use and the deadline. Then test the route once a year with a dummy notice, because a route that exists on paper often fails in practice.

What is a prior-knowledge or prior-notice date, and why does it matter?

Some policies limit cover by reference to what the company or its officers knew before a given date, or to notices given under an earlier policy. These dates can exclude a matter that began before the policy was placed, even if the claim arrives after it. Ask the broker to identify every such date in the policy, to say which events they affect, and to confirm the answer in writing. Record the answer in the board minutes in plain language that a non-lawyer can follow.

Does the policy distinguish between the company and its individuals?

It may, and the distinction often matters more than readers expect. Cover for the company and cover for individual directors and officers can sit in different parts of the policy, with different limits, retentions and conditions. A board that assumes one covers the other may leave an individual exposed in a dispute the company has already settled. Ask counsel to map who is insured under each part and whether any shared limit could be used up before an individual's claim is paid.

How should the board handle the limit and the retention?

The limit is the most the insurer will pay under the policy, often shared across all insureds and all claims in the period. The retention is the amount the company bears before cover starts. A board should know both figures, whether the limit is shared with other covers, and whether defence costs erode the limit. Ask the finance lead to model one large claim and one run of smaller claims against the limit, and report the result to the board.

Does a change of control or a corporate transaction affect the cover?

Some policies contain provisions that change how cover operates after a merger, acquisition or change of control, such as a run-off or a change in the period covered. The effect depends entirely on the wording, so there is no general answer to offer here. Ask counsel to identify those provisions before any transaction is discussed at board level, and ask the broker to say what the company would need to buy or extend if the transaction proceeds.

Who should be told when the policy is renewed or changed?

The renewal is the point at which the company is most likely to change its answers to the insurer's questions, and the insurer will rely on those answers. Make sure the chair, the audit committee and the person responsible for the disclosure form all see the renewal submission before it goes out. Ask whether any statement in the submission would be affected by something the board already knows, and if so, have counsel check the wording before it is sent.

What should a board do if it cannot get clear answers?

Take the question to counsel, not to the broker alone, and ask for the answer in writing with the policy clause cited. If the answer still turns on an ambiguous phrase, the board should treat that phrase as a risk and decide whether to negotiate clearer wording at renewal. Where a regulator or a professional body has issued guidance on insurance disclosure in the company's jurisdiction, ask counsel to confirm whether it applies. We have not verified any such guidance for this primer.

When does the company need a lawyer or an insurance specialist?

Whenever the question turns on the meaning of a policy term, the effect of a notice, the consequence of a transaction or the company's disclosure duties. These are legal and technical matters, and the answer depends on the exact wording and the jurisdiction. A board can ask the right questions without a specialist, but it should not rely on its own reading of the wording for any decision that could affect a claim.

The mistake behind most of these

The mistake behind most of these questions is treating D&O cover as a fixed asset that sits in the balance sheet until someone needs it. It is a contract with conditions, and the conditions do most of the work. Boards tend to delegate the policy to the finance lead or the broker, approve the renewal on the basis of the limit and the premium, and move on. The wording is then read for the first time by a lawyer in the middle of a dispute, which is the worst moment to learn what it says. The fix is not technical. It is a habit of asking, each year, what the policy would do in three situations the company actually faces, and writing the answers down before anyone needs them.

What to do next is small and specific. Ask the broker for the full wording this week, name one director as the owner of the review, and put the questions in this primer on the next audit or risk committee agenda. Ask counsel to produce a one-page note on the definitions, the exclusions and the notice conditions, and ask the finance lead to model one large claim against the limit. The board should then compare the note with the risk register and decide which gaps it will close at renewal and which it will accept, with the reason minuted. None of this needs a new policy. It needs the existing one read properly, by the people who will have to rely on it.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.