Outgrace, home

Handling employee grievances before they become disputes

A question-and-answer primer on receiving, investigating and documenting a workplace grievance, and on where the official sources stop short.

A grievance is usually small when it arrives and expensive by the time it reaches a tribunal or a regulator. The gap between those two states is nearly always time, and what fills that gap is the record: who was told what, when, and what anyone did about it. This primer answers the questions a founder, director or human resources lead asks before the first complaint lands and again once it has. It reflects our own judgement. The official sources we were given say less about this subject than it deserves, and the answers below say so where it matters.

Who is this primer for, and what is the one thing to remember?

It is for the person who receives a complaint from an employee and has to decide what happens next. That is usually a line manager, a human resources lead, or a founder in a company that has neither. The one thing to remember is that a grievance is a request to have something put right, and the way you respond becomes the evidence later. Treat every complaint as a record in the making, including the ones that look minor. Those are the ones nobody writes down, and therefore the ones nobody can defend.

What counts as a grievance, and what does not?

A grievance is a formal complaint by an employee about their treatment, a decision that affects them, or working conditions they believe are wrong. Pay, hours, a change to their role and a dispute with a colleague can all fall within it. A complaint that alleges discrimination usually needs a separate track, which the questions below cover. The distinction matters because sending a complaint down the wrong route can turn a fixable problem into a legal one. Decide the category in writing on the day the complaint arrives.

Do we need a written grievance procedure before a complaint arrives?

Yes, in our judgement, and it should exist before anyone needs it. None of the three official sources sets out grievance steps. The gov.uk employing people hub lists topics such as employee rights and changes to contracts but gives no procedure, and the canada.ca jobs page lists labour relations programmes without detail. A procedure should name the first point of contact, the stages, the rough time each stage should take, and the place where the written record is kept. One page is enough for most small companies.

Who should receive and assess the grievance?

Someone who did not take the decision being challenged and who has the authority to act on the outcome. In a small company that may be the founder, working with an outside adviser. In a larger one it is usually a senior manager from another team. Avoid the line manager who is the subject of the complaint, even if they are the only person in the building on the day. Write down who received the grievance, when, and what they were told to do next.

How quickly should we respond?

Acknowledge the grievance in writing promptly, and say what happens next and roughly when. None of the official sources in this piece gives a fixed deadline, so any timing rule must come from the law in your own jurisdiction, which you should confirm with an adviser. Silence is the commonest failure. An employee who hears nothing for weeks will assume the worst, and the file will show that the company let the matter drift. A short acknowledgement costs almost nothing and protects both sides.

Should we investigate before we meet the employee?

Usually not. Meet the employee first to understand the complaint in their own words, then decide what needs checking. Keep the investigation proportionate: identify the facts in dispute, the people who can speak to them, and the documents that exist. Write down the questions you asked and the answers you received. Let the employee see the notes of their own meeting so they can correct errors before you rely on them. A mistake caught at that stage costs an afternoon; one found at a hearing costs far more.

What if the grievance alleges discrimination?

Treat it as a different and higher-stakes matter, and get legal advice early. For US employers, the EEOC's home page points to a page on how to file a charge of employment discrimination, and to separate guidance on the rights and responsibilities of employees and of employers under equal employment law. It also describes a separate complaint route for discrimination by a federal agency. The UK and Canada have their own regimes, and the sources make clear that the laws differ and are not interchangeable. Do not assume a process that works in one country applies in another.

What records should we keep?

Keep the written grievance, the acknowledgement, dated notes of every meeting, the evidence you examined, the decision, and the reasons for it. Write notes as events happen, in plain language, and separate what was said from what you concluded. Store the file where the people who need it can reach it and where nobody named in the complaint can edit it. Ask an adviser how long to keep the records and how data protection rules apply in your country, because those answers differ by place.

Does the manager named in the grievance take part?

They should know what is alleged and have a fair chance to respond, in writing or in a meeting. They should not decide the outcome, run the investigation, or see the employee's confidential material beyond what the process strictly requires. Keep the process as confidential as you can, and tell both parties what that means in practice, so that nobody is surprised later by who knew what. A manager who feels ambushed will often become the second grievance.

Can we take action against an employee who raises a grievance?

That is a question for an employment lawyer in your jurisdiction, and the official sources in this piece do not answer it. As a matter of judgement, any adverse step taken soon after someone raises a complaint deserves review by someone outside the matter before it happens. Ask the lawyer to look at the timing, the stated reasons, and the paper trail together. The question is rarely about one document. It is about whether the sequence of events looks like a response to the complaint.

What if the employee disagrees with the outcome?

Offer an appeal, state the grounds on which it can be made, and set a time limit you can keep. Let someone who did not take the original decision hear it. Record the appeal and its outcome in the same file as the original grievance, so that the whole sequence can be read in one place. An employee who believes they were heard, even if they lose, is far less likely to take the matter to the next stage. A dismissed appeal with clear reasons is a much better document than a refusal with none.

When should we bring in outside help?

Bring in an employment lawyer as soon as a complaint concerns discrimination, dismissal, pay, or a possible breach of contract, or when you are unsure which rules apply. Where your country runs a conciliation service, ask what it covers and whether it will help before the dispute becomes formal. Our sources do not confirm which services exist in any particular jurisdiction, so check directly with the relevant government body. Outside help is cheapest at the start and most expensive once positions have hardened.

How do we know whether our procedure is working?

Look at three things over a year: how many grievances reached the appeal stage, how many were resolved at the first meeting, and how many produced a file you would be comfortable showing a tribunal or regulator. Read a sample of closed files as if you were the other side. Gaps in the reasoning are usually visible to a stranger long before they are visible to the person who wrote the note. Review the procedure after any grievance that went badly, and record what changed.

The mistake behind most of these

The mistake behind most of these questions is treating a grievance as a matter of atmosphere rather than of record. A manager hears a complaint, reads the mood of the room, and decides the matter is closed because nobody has raised it again. Months later the same employee arrives with a solicitor's letter, or a charge, and the company cannot show what was said, what was checked, or why it decided as it did. None of the three official sources listed for this piece makes that argument in so many words. The record makes it every time. Build the file as you go, because it cannot be reconstructed afterwards without losing something important.

This week, do three things. First, find out whether your company has a written grievance procedure and whether it names one person who receives complaints. If it does not, write a one-page version with a named receiver and a single place where records go. Second, list every country where your people work, because the three jurisdictions covered by the official sources differ and one country's answer cannot be applied to another. Third, book time with an employment adviser in each of those places to review the procedure and any timing rules. Ask them to read the procedure as if they were the employee, and to tell you where it would fail.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.