Outgrace
OutgraceThe Leadership Magazine, home
LeadershipHow-to guide

Giving direct feedback to a senior leader who reports to you

Preparation, a five-step structure and the legal limits our sources do cover. The sources say little about how status affects reception, so that part is our judgement.

Feedback, report back, business people, group, team, balloons
Photo: geralt / Pixabay

A senior person who reports to you has more to lose from a candid conversation than a junior one, and usually more ways to avoid hearing it. The feedback you owe them tends to wait until it arrives as a complaint from someone else, or as a resignation. This guide sets out how to prepare and deliver a direct conversation, and what to do afterwards. Our sources say very little on this subject, so the advice below is our judgement, and we have marked where it stops being sourced.

Before you start

Settle three things before you book the meeting. First, decide on the single behaviour or outcome you want to discuss. A list of six concerns tells a senior colleague that you have been keeping a file, and it makes the one that matters harder to hear. Second, check your own evidence. Write down what you saw, when it happened, who was affected and what resulted, and keep that separate from what you think it means. Third, decide what you want to change, and whether you would accept a different route to the same result.

Then check whether the conversation touches anything with legal weight. The only source in our set that addresses this is the US Office of Personnel Management (OPM). Its memo says federal law protects employees who report misconduct, and that the protection extends to employees in performance, conduct, suitability and equal employment opportunity processes. It also says agencies must take specific steps to protect such employees from retaliation, and that a complaint about an official's action runs against the agency, not the official personally. The memo covers federal agencies in the United States only. If your organisation is one of them, or if the senior person has raised a concern with you, put the matter to HR or legal before the meeting. Outside US federal employment, our sources say nothing, and you should ask a lawyer what applies where you work.

Before the meeting, run through a short check. It takes ten minutes and it will show you whether the conversation is ready.

  • Can you state the behaviour in one sentence, without the word 'attitude'?
  • Do you have at least two dated examples, and do you know who else was affected?
  • Have you asked whether the person has raised any concern with you, or with HR, that touches your own decisions?
  • Have you written down one outcome you would accept, and one you would not?
  1. Step 1

    Choose a private room and a fixed time

    Do not give feedback in a meeting with others present, and do not squeeze it in before a board pack is due. Ask for thirty minutes in a slot you will not cut short. In our experience, a senior person who sees 'feedback' as the subject line arrives braced. That is acceptable, provided you have a clear opening ready.

  2. Step 2

    State the purpose in the first minute

    Say what you want to discuss and what you want from the discussion. For example: you have noticed that deadlines on the shared programme slip after the weekly review, and you want to understand why together. Avoid opening with praise followed by 'but'. Experienced people tend to recognise that device, and it only delays the point you came to make.

  3. Step 3

    Describe what you saw, not what it means

    Give one or two specific examples, with dates, the people affected and what was said or done. Describe the behaviour, not the motive or character behind it. What usually goes wrong here is that the feedback slides into a verdict on the person. A verdict gives them something to argue with and nothing to fix.

  4. Step 4

    Ask for their account and listen to it

    Ask what they saw, and what constraints they were working under. Then stop talking for longer than feels comfortable. If their account contains a fact you did not know, change your view in front of them and say what has changed. Leaders who skip this step often find later that the problem sat in a resourcing decision, not in the person they were correcting.

  5. Step 5

    Agree one action, an owner and a date

    Name one thing each of you will do, and the date you will check it. Write it down the same day and send a brief note to the other person. If there is nothing concrete to agree, say so, and name the date you will return to the question. A conversation that ends in warm words and no date tends to come back in six months, in a worse form.

Seniority changes the room more than the message. A senior person may have more time, more allies and fewer reasons to take a remark from their manager at face value. Our sources contain no evidence on how status affects the way feedback is received, and we have not found a study we could cite here. What follows is our judgement. Do not soften the substance because the person is senior, and do not sharpen it either. Use the same examples, the same questions and the same close that you would use with anyone else. What changes is the amount of time you give them to respond, and you should give them more of it.

Where people go wrong

Most failed feedback conversations fail in one of three ways. The first is delay. The leader waits until the problem is large enough to justify a formal process, and by then the senior person reasonably feels ambushed. The second is hedging. So many qualifiers are attached to the message that it disappears, and the person leaves believing nothing needs to change. The third is more dangerous. If the senior person has recently raised a concern about your own conduct or decisions, feedback can quietly become a response to that concern. In the federal setting, the OPM memo says agencies must protect employees from retaliation and must take specific steps to do so. Whatever your setting, keep the two conversations apart and let the people responsible for the concern handle it.

Should I send the feedback in writing first?

Write your notes, not the message. A written account sent beforehand gives the senior person time to prepare a defence, and it turns a conversation into a document. Send a short calendar note that names the topic, and leave the detail for the room. If your HR team has a policy on written feedback, follow it, and ask them before you assume it does not apply.

What if the senior person becomes angry or defensive?

Expect some emotion. It does not mean the conversation has failed. Pause, acknowledge what they appear to feel, and return to the example. If the meeting turns into an argument about whether you are fair, offer to continue after a day, and bring a note of what you heard. Do not agree to a change you do not believe in just to end the discomfort.

What if my evidence turns out to be incomplete?

Say so. Feedback given with an honest margin for error lands better than feedback delivered as settled fact. If their account changes your view, tell them plainly and say what has changed. That is a form of respect, and it shows the conversation was an exchange rather than a verdict.

Do I need a named feedback model?

Our sources name no feedback model, so we cannot say which one has the best record, and we have not used one here. Any structure that makes you describe, ask and agree will do. Choose one you can remember under pressure, and rehearse it with a colleague you trust before you use it on someone whose opinion of you matters.

This week, do three things. Write down the single behaviour you want to discuss, with two dated examples. Ask HR or legal whether anything in your setting changes how you should proceed, and if you work in US federal employment, ask them to confirm which of the OPM memo's protections apply. Then book thirty minutes in a room with a door that closes, and do not move it. Discomfort on both sides is normal in a first conversation of this kind, and it says little about whether the feedback is right.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.