Outgrace, home
LeadershipExplainer

Why leadership pipelines lose women, and how to audit yours

Promotion, assignment and sponsorship records show where women leave the pipeline. Start with the data you already hold, and be clear about what it cannot tell you.

A leadership pipeline is the sequence of hiring, promotion, assignment and sponsorship that produces the people who run a company. Women leave it at points most leaders cannot see, because the reports they read measure outcomes rather than the steps that produced them.

How it works

A pipeline leaks at each stage, and a leak at one stage shrinks the pool for the next. Hiring decides who enters. Promotion decides who moves up. Assignment decides who gets the work that makes someone ready for a senior role, and sponsorship decides whose name is said in the rooms where the senior roles are filled. Each stage takes its own share, and the sums are simple. The difficulty is that the data needed to add them up is usually held by HR, finance and the business units, and rarely in one file.

The clearest public picture in our sources concerns the entry and senior levels. According to the Pew Research Center, women made up 52.2% of US managerial and professional occupations in 2013, up from 30.6% in 1968. The same research says women still lag far behind men in senior management positions, despite wider gains at entry level. On that account, the leak sits above the first management rung rather than at the door.

Pew's framing matters for any audit. It reports that women have outnumbered men in US college enrolment and completion since the 1990s, and it describes the pipeline as widening. On that evidence, the supply of qualified women is not the main problem. A leader who counts only how many women they hire will miss the point at which the numbers fall away, and that point is usually a decision someone made about a person, not a fact about the labour market.

The UK's gender pay gap service measures something narrower. According to the GOV.UK service, the gender pay gap is the difference between the average pay of men and women in an organisation. Employers with 250 or more employees must report this data each year, on a set date, and the public service lets users search and compare the figures by company or sector. An average can tell you that pay differs. It cannot tell you whether the cause is promotion, assignment, or pay within a grade. That is the work of the audit.

Family responsibilities are the explanation leaders reach for first, and Pew's survey gives it a place. Pew reports that about one in five adults say women's family responsibilities are a major reason for fewer women in top leadership. The same report cites economic research indicating that motherhood-related career interruptions may make advancement harder for women. That is a claim about career breaks, which your own records can show. Test it against your data rather than assuming it, and do not treat it as the whole answer.

Pew also reports that the public sees women ahead of men on honesty and ethics, on fair pay and benefits, and on mentoring young employees, and sees men ahead on willingness to take risks and on negotiating profitable deals. These are perceptions, not performance records. They matter to an audit because they are the same kind of judgement that decides who receives a stretch assignment, and a manager who holds them may never write them down.

Women's share of US managerial and professional occupations, 2013 (Pew Research Center)
52.2%
Women's share of Fortune 500 boards as of 2013, up from 10% in 1995 (Pew Research Center)
17%
Women serving as Fortune 500 CEOs, roughly 5%, none in 1995 (Pew Research Center)
26

Who it affects

The audience is wider than the boardroom, but the numbers at the top give the sharpest signal. Pew reports that women held 19% of seats in the 114th Congress, with 104 women serving, about double the share of twenty years earlier. In US corporate leadership, Pew reports 17% of Fortune 500 board seats held by women as of 2013 and 26 women serving as Fortune 500 CEOs. Both figures are a long way from parity, and both sit at the end of the pipeline rather than at its start.

Pew's survey was conducted online with 1,835 randomly selected US adults between 12 and 21 November 2014. Its findings describe what the public expects, not what any given company does. That is useful context for a leadership team, because the expectations a workforce holds shape how it reads a promotion decision long before anyone reviews the data. Pew reports that 53% of respondents expect men to keep holding more top business executive posts, and 44% say parity in those posts is only a matter of time.

UK employers with 250 or more employees are the group our sources identify as having a reporting duty, and anyone running one already holds a data set they can use. Employers below that threshold are not covered by the same duty, but the questions in this piece apply to any company that wants more women in senior roles. The leak does not stop at a reporting threshold, and a smaller company is often better placed to read its own records closely, because there are fewer of them.

What leaders get wrong

  • Treating the pay gap figure as the audit. An average is a summary. It cannot show who was promoted, who was passed over, or who was given the work that leads to a senior role.
  • Auditing outcomes without the pool. A promotion rate means little until you know who was eligible and who was put forward. Count at each stage, not only at the end.
  • Assuming assignments are neutral. Stretch work and client-facing roles often decide who is ready for the next level. Record who receives them, and at what point in their careers.
  • Believing sponsorship is informal and therefore harmless. If senior people advocate for some staff and not others, the pattern will appear in the records before anyone names it.
  • Reading public opinion as evidence about your own company. Pew's findings describe what people expect. Your company's records are the evidence, and they answer a narrower question.

What to do about it

Start with a dated extract, not a survey. Take the last three years of hiring, promotion, assignment and leaving records, and cut each by sex and by level. In our experience, the first cut shows where the drop happens, and the second shows whether it lies in who applies, who is put forward, or who is chosen. Before you pull a single figure, write down who counts as eligible for each step. A sensible test is whether a gap at one stage survives when you compare only people who were eligible at that stage.

Then ask the questions the pay report cannot answer. Did women wait longer between promotions than men at the same level? Did people who took a career break return to the same path, and if not, where did it diverge? Who held the assignments that led to the top roles, and which senior leaders agreed to sponsor them? Each question needs a named owner and a number you can check again next year. A question with no owner tends to produce a chart that nobody acts on.

Use the structure of an employer action plan to write up what you find. Plans published on the GOV.UK service set out the steps an employer has taken to address its pay gap, and some include support for employees experiencing menopause. A plan that names each step, its owner and its date is harder to shelve than a set of charts. The same discipline works for an internal write-up, even where no reporting duty applies.

Be clear about the limits of what we found. The sources for this piece cover the UK reporting rule and US survey evidence on the pipeline. They do not include equality-body guidance on promotion or assignment, and the NBER homepage we checked had no content on promotion, assignment, sponsorship or pipeline attrition. Before you build an audit on those topics, read your equality regulator's guidance directly, and treat this article as a method for asking questions, not as a statement of what the law requires.

Any finding about who was promoted, assigned or paid less is a legal matter. Take it to employment counsel before you change a decision that affects a named person. If the findings raise questions you cannot answer internally, your equality regulator is the right place to ask them. Keep the audit separate from individual performance reviews, so that no single manager's file becomes the only evidence.

The gender pay gap is the difference between the average pay of men and women in an organisation.

GOV.UK gender pay gap service (service page), gender-pay-gap.service.gov.uk

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.