Outgrace, home
LeadershipData brief

What the research does not yet tell you about leader turnover

Three sources we checked contain no measured cost of replacing a manager. Before a board prices a leadership change, it needs its own estimate, built on its own data.

The research we checked does not put a number on what it costs a team when its manager leaves. We looked at three sources: the World Bank, the National Bureau of Economic Research and the Pew Research Center. None of them measures the effect of leadership change on team output or on staff retention. That is a finding in its own right, and it changes what a careful leader can say in a board paper this week.

What the sources contain

The World Bank material we reviewed covers other subjects. Its International Debt Report 2026 puts developing countries' external debt at a record $9.4 trillion, according to the World Bank. That figure concerns national borrowing and says nothing about managers or teams. The National Bureau of Economic Research holds no peer-reviewed study of manager replacement and no team-performance data in the material we checked. Pew Research Center's survey material on chatbots and election information reports that 8% of U.S. adults use chatbots for election information, according to Pew. It also says nothing about leadership change.

The one leadership change in these sources is a personal one. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, Helena Foulkes was elected Governor of Rhode Island on November 3, 2026, and resigned from the NBER board of directors on her election. Foulkes had served on that board since April 2020 as an at-large member. The NBER records the departure. It does not report any effect on team output, and it does not measure one.

What this leaves open

The gap is real and it matters. A board that wants to weigh a manager's replacement will reach for a figure, and the figures in circulation are often older, narrower or sourced from consultancies. Our researcher's note on this brief says the angle needs peer-reviewed management or labour-economics sources, and the three outlets provided are not those. We have not filled the gap with figures from memory. Any number a reader meets in a deck on this subject should be traced to a named study before it is repeated.

How to weigh the cost yourself

In our experience, the most useful estimate is the one built from your own records. Start with the time the role stood empty, the people who left the team in the following year, and the output the team delivered in the quarters either side of the change. Those three measures are already in most companies' systems, even if no one has put them side by side. A replacement cost that rests on your numbers can be argued with. A borrowed number cannot.

  • How many weeks did the role stand empty, and who covered it?
  • How many people left the team within twelve months of the change, and were they the ones you expected to lose?
  • What did the team deliver in the quarter before and the two quarters after the change?
  • Which of the new manager's early decisions were reversed within a year?
  • Which of these figures does finance already hold, and which would take HR a month to find?

Keep the estimate modest and label its assumptions. A single-team comparison from your own business tells a board more than a confident figure with no origin. If the estimate will shape a decision on pay, succession or the timing of a change, have finance and HR check the method, and take HR or employment advice on any aspect that touches contracts or redundancy.

What to do this week

Ask your finance lead for the three measures above for the last two leadership changes in your business. If the records do not exist, write that down as a finding. Then ask whoever is preparing the next board paper on succession to name the source for any cost of replacement they plan to use. If they cannot name one, the paper should say the cost has not been measured. That sentence is less satisfying than a figure, but a board can act on it honestly.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.