Outgrace, home

One-to-one meetings: what the research can and cannot say

Five sources checked for evidence on manager one-to-ones turned up nothing on meetings, feedback or engagement. This piece is held until a relevant source is found.

A data brief on one-to-one meetings needs data. The five sources assigned for this piece do not supply any. The National Bureau of Economic Research, Brookings, Pew Research Center, Stanford Graduate School of Business and Harvard Business School were each checked against the topic of manager feedback, workplace engagement and performance. None of them covers those subjects in the material we were given. The two closest mentions are adjacent: a teaching method at Harvard Business School, and a passing remark about a team member's outlook at Stanford Graduate School of Business. Neither includes a study or a figure.

What we could not establish

We could not establish how often managers should meet their direct reports, how long those meetings should last, or whether a fixed agenda improves outcomes compared with an open conversation. We could not establish whether one-to-one meetings affect engagement, retention or output at all. Those are the questions a leader would need answered before changing a calendar. A reader who wants a number should look for a peer-reviewed study that measures engagement or performance directly, names its sample, and reports how the meetings were run. Without one, any figure attached to this topic would be ours to invent, and we will not do that.

The gap matters for practical reasons. Many organisations set meeting frequency by habit or by a consultant's rule of thumb. A rule of thumb is not evidence, and a board that adopts one should ask where it came from. In our judgement, a sensible first test is to write down the decision each one-to-one is meant to support, then check after a quarter whether those decisions were made faster or with better information. That is a test a team can run without waiting for a study. It does not prove that meetings improve performance.

What to do next

Hold this piece until a source with relevant data is added. The brief should be rerun against research that covers manager feedback and workplace engagement directly, with each figure attributed to its publisher and year. Until then, the honest guidance for a leader is narrow. Keep your current one-to-one practice unless you have a reason to change it, and treat any claim about frequency or format as unsupported until its source has been read. If your organisation is setting a policy on these meetings, ask for the study behind it before the policy is written.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.