Outgrace, home

Performance improvement plans: the questions leaders ask

A performance improvement plan is only as fair as the record behind it. Answers on documentation, timing and proportion, drawn from official employment guidance and standard HR practice.

A performance improvement plan is often the first formal step a manager takes with an underperforming employee. In our experience, it is also the step most often revisited later, by a reviewer, a tribunal or a new manager. This primer is for line managers, HR leads and founders who expect to write one this quarter. The one thing to remember is simple: the plan is only as fair as the record behind it. None of the three official sources reviewed for this piece mentions performance improvement plans by name. The answers that follow are therefore standard HR practice and editorial judgement, anchored wherever possible to the employment rules that do apply, and they are not legal advice.

What is a performance improvement plan?

It is a written document that sets out a specific shortfall in someone's work, what acceptable performance looks like, the support the employer will provide, and the date on which progress will be reviewed. Its purpose is to make a problem visible to the person who has it, while there is still time to fix it. A sensible design treats the plan as a step before formal discipline, not a replacement for it. Your own policy may use a different name or a different structure, so check it before you draft anything.

When should a manager start one?

Start when a specific, observable gap has been raised with the employee at least once and has not closed. A plan that arrives without warning reads as a decision already taken, and that impression is hard to undo. Before you write anything, work out what is actually going on. A skill gap, a workload problem, a health issue and a dispute with a colleague each call for a different response. If the cause is unclear, a conversation comes before a document, and a plan should only follow once the facts are clear.

What should the plan say before anyone signs it?

Name three to five things, each stated as something a person could see or measure: the report delivered on time, the error rate on invoices, the number of client calls completed in a week. Give a start date, a review date and the specific support on offer, such as training, shadowing or a temporarily reduced workload. Write the standard the employee must meet, not the adjectives a manager finds frustrating. Leave out anything you cannot evidence, however strongly you feel about it.

What records should the manager keep, and for how long?

Keep a dated note of every conversation, including what was said and what the employee agreed to do. Keep copies of the emails, reports and figures that show the gap. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says, on its employers page, that "The laws enforced by EEOC require employers to keep certain records, regardless of whether a charge has been filed against them." None of the sources reviewed gives a retention period, so ask your HR lead or an adviser how long your jurisdiction expects records to be kept.

What should we do if the employee raises a concern during the plan?

Treat the concern as information and deal with it before the next review goes ahead. The UK tribunal service advises trying to resolve a dispute directly before making a claim, and names Acas as an alternative route for resolving disputes. If the concern touches on discrimination, pregnancy, disability or another legal right, pause the process and take advice. Record what you did, when you did it and why. A plan that carries on regardless of a complaint is difficult to defend later.

What evidence will be examined if the matter goes further?

The UK tribunal guidance gives emails and witness statements as examples of the evidence a claim may need. Those are the documents a reviewer will reach for first, so the file should be readable without you in the room. Write each note as though a stranger will read it in two years, with dates, the employee's own words where you have them, and the plain facts of what was observed. Leave out opinions about character, which give a reviewer nothing they can test and invite the question of whether the plan was really about performance.

Should we check for protected grounds before starting?

Yes, and before the first meeting rather than after it. The EEOC lists the grounds covered by federal anti-discrimination law in the US as race, colour, religion, sex (including pregnancy), national origin, age (40 or older), disability and genetic information. A shortfall that is linked to pregnancy, a health condition or age can change the response you need, and it can change the risk. Coverage also varies by employer type, number of employees and the kind of discrimination alleged, so confirm where your organisation sits before relying on any general rule.

How much time does an employee have to challenge a plan or a dismissal?

Deadlines are strict, and they run from different events. In the UK, an unfair dismissal claim runs from the date employment ended, while a discrimination claim runs from the most recent incident in the claim. The UK guidance warns that a missed deadline may bar a claim, even if the person was trying to resolve the dispute directly. In the US, the EEOC says a charge must be filed before a lawsuit against the employer, and that time limits for filing a charge are strict. Do not assume a plan pauses any of these clocks; take advice on that point before you rely on it.

Do the same rules apply in Canada and Northern Ireland?

Not in the same way, and the sources do not settle the detail. Canada.ca lists federal and provincial labour laws and workplace standards as government resources, but the page gives no specifics on performance management. Northern Ireland has a separate claims route from England, Wales and Scotland, according to the UK tribunal guidance. An employer operating across these places should obtain local employment advice before using one template everywhere, because a document that is sound in one place can be weak in another.

When is ending employment a reasonable outcome, and who should decide?

The sources do not answer this, and no general test applies everywhere. In our experience, a dismissal decision should rest on a plan that was written clearly, a review that took place as set, and a file that shows the employee had a fair chance to respond. A second senior person who was not involved in the day-to-day management should check the decision. Take advice from an employment lawyer or qualified adviser in the relevant jurisdiction before any notice is given, because a dismissal carries legal exposure that a magazine article cannot assess for you.

The mistake behind most of these

Most of these questions come back to one error: treating the plan as the decision, rather than as the record of a decision. Managers draft the plan quickly because it feels like action, then reconstruct the file later from memory and scattered emails. The result reads as a verdict reached before the employee had a fair chance to answer it. The dates look tidy, but the evidence is thin, and the gaps only show when someone outside the team reads the file. The fix is slower and less dramatic. Write the notes on the day, put the standard in writing before the first review, and check the file against the questions above before anything is signed.

What to do next is more practical than it sounds. This week, pick the one performance gap that is most visible and describe it in terms another person could check. Gather the notes, emails and figures that already show it, and set aside anything that is opinion. Put the protected-ground question and the jurisdiction question to your HR lead or an adviser before the first meeting, not after. Book that meeting with a clear start date and review date, and tell the employee in writing what support will be offered. If the employee raises a concern at any stage, stop, record it and get advice before you go further.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.