
The Right to Repair Meets the Right to Rewrite
Owners and independent garages want the same access to a vehicle’s computer that dealers have. Regulators want the emissions software inside it left alone. In 2026 both arguments gained ground at once.
Brad Gintz site (via bradgintz.com)
On 21 May 2026 the House Energy and Commerce Committee voted 48 to 1 for H.R. 7389, the Motor Vehicle Modernization Act of 2026. Folded into it was a shrunken version of the REPAIR Act, the bill the independent repair trade had pushed through two Congresses. What survived, according to the trade publication Repairer Driven News, was the substance of an agreement carmakers and the aftermarket had signed in 2014, under which manufacturers make repair information, tools and diagnostic codes available to independent shops as well as dealers. The broader provisions, on wireless telematics data and aftermarket access to diagnostic tools, were largely turned into a Federal Trade Commission study.
The bill’s lead sponsor, Representative Neal Dunn, voted for the package and said: “I’m extremely disappointed that the version included in the package we vote on will not include the true REPAIR Act.” The carmakers’ trade body, Auto Innovators, said the committee had “essentially codified an existing Memorandum of Understanding established in 2014”. The CAR Coalition of aftermarket groups said codifying the MOU “does nothing to expand consumer choice”.
Four months earlier, on 21 January, the Justice Department had moved in a direction that pleased a different constituency. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche ordered federal prosecutors to stop bringing criminal cases over tampering with vehicles’ emissions software, and to drop pending ones, according to a memo reported by CBS News. The department said it would still pursue civil enforcement “when appropriate”.
These are two stories about the same small piece of hardware: the diagnostic port.
What the port is for
The Clean Air Act requires vehicle manufacturers to install on-board diagnostic systems that watch the emissions equipment for malfunction or deterioration and alert the driver to get it repaired. When such a system detects a fault, it records a diagnostic trouble code; on some faults it can also reduce engine performance until the problem is fixed. That description comes from the federal government’s own complaint in a case discussed below.
So the port began as an instrument of emissions control. It became the front door of almost every modern repair, because the fault codes it exposes are where diagnosis starts. And because a vehicle’s engine computer can be reprogrammed through it, it is also the route by which that software is changed.
Brad Gintz, a Louisiana mechanic who co-founded the connected-diagnostics company EZ LYNK, describes the repair-side case in terms of price. “Instead of needing a $12,000 scanner or proprietary equipment, even small-town or backyard mechanics can access high-level diagnostic power,” he told Authority Magazine in April 2026. His shorter version names the target: disruption is justified where a system ends up “forcing someone to pay $300 to program a $20 key because only proprietary equipment can do it.”
The repair argument
The case for opening the port is well documented. In May 2021 the Federal Trade Commission sent Congress a report, Nixing the Fix, which found “scant evidence to support manufacturers’ justifications for repair restrictions”. Voters have been blunter. In November 2020, Massachusetts approved a ballot measure extending the state’s right-to-repair law to wireless telematics by 75 per cent to 25 per cent on unofficial returns.
The economics push the same way. The average American light vehicle was a record 12.8 years old in 2025, by S&P Global Mobility’s count, and older vehicles need more work. Truck operators spent 21.5 cents a mile on repair and maintenance in 2025, up from 19.8 cents, according to the American Transportation Research Institute. Every hour a truck spends waiting for a dealer slot is an hour it is not earning.
Some diagnostics companies go further and argue that the expert need not be in the room at all. Gintz’s version, in a March 2026 article for Vehicle Service Pros, borrows from medicine: a remote specialist reads the data, a local technician turns the spanner. “Smart scan tools won’t replace technicians any more than remote medical diagnostic centers replace doctors,” he wrote, “but they change who is able to perform accurate diagnostics.”
The emissions argument
The case for guarding the port is also well documented. In November 2020 EPA’s Air Enforcement Division estimated that emissions controls had been removed from more than 550,000 diesel pickups in the previous decade, about 15 per cent of those certified with controls, with lifetime excess nitrogen oxides equal to adding more than nine million compliant trucks to the road. The most common defeat devices, the agency explained, are software “tunes”; “delete tunes” reprogram the engine and override the diagnostic system “so the tampered vehicle will operate without any diagnostic trouble codes (DTCs) or the ‘check engine’ light”, even with its after-treatment partly or wholly removed.
Enforcement followed. The Louisiana tuning company PPEI and its owner pleaded guilty in 2022 and agreed to pay US$3.1 million in criminal fines and civil penalties; the owner had claimed to have tuned more than 175,000 vehicles. In January 2026, two weeks before the Justice Department’s memo, the parts distributor Meyer Distributing agreed to a US$7.4 million civil penalty over more than 90,000 devices, Fleet Maintenance reported.
Then the climate changed. In November 2025 President Trump pardoned Troy Lake, a Wyoming diesel mechanic who had served seven months in prison for disabling emissions controls, CBS reported. The January memo followed. The legal theory behind it, according to CBS, holds that the software associated with emissions controls is not “required to be maintained” under the Clean Air Act, so tampering with it can be pursued only as a civil matter. Career prosecutors and EPA lawyers had reached the opposite conclusion, the network reported. Civil penalties still stand: Fleet Maintenance puts them at US$45,268 per tampered engine and US$4,527 per defeat-device sale.
Where the two meet
The hardest case sits where these arguments overlap, and one has just ended without an answer. In 2021 the United States sued EZ LYNK, Gintz and his co-founder under the Clean Air Act, alleging that the company’s system, a plug-in device, a phone app and a cloud library of third-party software, was a “defeat device” because it let drivers install delete tunes. The company has always described its products as “content-neutral pass-through scan tools”. A district judge found the defeat-device claim plausible but dismissed it under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, the law that protects online platforms from liability for users’ content. In August 2025 the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed on Section 230, holding that the complaint plausibly alleged the company had “directly and materially contributed to” the creation of delete tunes. On 10 July 2026 both sides agreed to dismiss the case with prejudice. No court found liability; none ruled the product lawful.
Gintz’s own statement on the dismissal is the repair argument in its purest form: “Every driver deserves to know what’s wrong with their vehicle and to choose who fixes it, whether that’s a dealership, an independent shop, or in their own driveway.” The government’s argument, never tested at trial, was that some of what flowed through his company’s cloud was not repair at all.
The question underneath is going to get larger. Ford’s 2020–2025 Super Duty trucks, for example, can now receive software updates through EZ LYNK’s platform instead of at a dealer. “This is about restoring choice,” Gintz said when the company announced it in August 2025. The same path that carries a manufacturer’s update can carry anything else a vehicle’s computer will accept. Right-to-repair law has mostly been written about reading data and fixing faults. It has said much less about rewriting the software that keeps a vehicle legal.
What to watch
Three things will decide how far the port opens. First, the FTC study that the House committee substituted for telematics access, and whether Congress acts on it. Second, whether federal civil enforcement against defeat devices continues at its previous pace now that criminal cases have been dropped; a future administration could reverse either policy. Third, whether any court ever answers the question the EZ Lynk case left behind: when a platform delivers someone else’s software into a vehicle, how much of the responsibility for that software is its own.
Gintz’s position on that is clear from everything he has said in public. “Competition drives innovation for people,” he told Authority Magazine, “monopolization drives exploitation of people.” The test for his industry is whether it can make that case to regulators as convincingly as it has made it to voters.
Sources
- Repairer Driven News, 26 May 2026 — repairerdrivennews.com/2026/05/26/u-s-house-committee-a… (opens in a new tab) - CBS News, 21 Jan 2026 — cbsnews.com/news/justice-department-auto-emissions-chea… (opens in a new tab) - Fleet Maintenance, 23 Jan 2026 — fleetmaintenance.com/equipment/emissions-and-efficiency… (opens in a new tab) - Complaint, United States v. EZ Lynk, SEZC et al., 8 Mar 2021, ¶¶29–31 (OBD requirements) — justice.gov/usao-sdny/press-release/file/1374621/dl (opens in a new tab) - FTC, Nixing the Fix, May 2021 — ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/nixing-fix-ftc-r… (opens in a new tab) ; coverage: sema.org/news-media/enews/2021/19/federal-trade-commiss… (opens in a new tab) - Ballotpedia News, 4 Nov 2020 — news.ballotpedia.org/2020/11/04/massachusetts-voters-ap… (opens in a new tab) - S&P Global Mobility, 2025 — aftermarketinsight.spglobal.com/news/4375/average-age-o… (opens in a new tab) - ATRI via FreightWaves, 15 Jul 2026 — freightwaves.com/news/trucking-costs-outpaced-consumer-… (opens in a new tab) - EPA Air Enforcement Division, 20 Nov 2020 — 19january2021snapshot.epa.gov/sites/static/files/2021-0… (opens in a new tab) - Insurance Journal, 16 Mar 2022 — insurancejournal.com/news/southcentral/2022/03/16/65839… (opens in a new tab) - Second Circuit opinion, 20 Aug 2025 — caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-2nd-circuit/117621620.html (opens in a new tab) - CourtListener docket, 1:21-cv-01986 — courtlistener.com/docket/59712913/united-states-v-ez-ly… (opens in a new tab) - EZ LYNK release, 28 Jul 2026 (syndicated) — manilatimes.net/2026/07/29/tmt-newswire/globenewswire/d… (opens in a new tab) - EZ LYNK release, 27 Aug 2025 — ezlynk.com/news/ez-lynk-puts-power-back-in-drivers-hand… (opens in a new tab) - Authority Magazine, 30 Apr 2026 — medium.com/authority-magazine/meet-the-disruptors-bradl… (opens in a new tab) - Vehicle Service Pros, 13 Mar 2026 — vehicleservicepros.com/training-and-resources/guest-blo… (opens in a new tab)


