Outgrace, home
StrategyFramework

Mapping strategic risk onto your value chain, one stage at a time

A method for placing strategic risks on each stage of a value chain, with one owner and one testable mitigation per risk, built on public risk-management sources.

Hourglass, money, time, investment, currency, finance
Photo: stevepb / Pixabay

Most strategic risk registers are arranged by department. Most value chains run across departments. A hypothetical provider group might track supplier concentration in procurement and staff shortages in human resources, and find that the two lists never meet, even though one failure feeds the other. The fix is to put each risk where the value is made, stage by stage, and to give each stage-risk a named owner and a mitigation someone can check. The method below is our judgement. It draws on the risk logic in four public sources, and it is not a healthcare standard. Where those sources say nothing about healthcare, we say so.

Chapter one: Pillar 1: Draw the chain as stages, not departments

Start by writing the chain as the sequence of stages that an input passes through before it reaches a customer or patient. Name each stage by what happens to the thing being made or delivered, not by the team that handles it. Five to eight stages is usually enough. Fewer stages hide the seams where risks collect, because a broad stage such as delivery covers too many decisions to own. More stages turn the map into an organisation chart with arrows. A sensible test is to ask the chief operating officer and the finance lead, separately, which stage absorbs most of their spending. If either cannot point to one, the map is missing a stage or has one stage too many.

Once the stages are written, attach a single executive to each. This is not the stage's manager; it is the person who answers for what happens there in front of the board. Do this before placing any risk. Leaders who skip it tend to place risks on stages that nobody has agreed to run, and the placements then drift. Keep the map to one page. If it does not fit on a page, the stages are probably too detailed for a strategic view, and the detail belongs in the operating plan for that stage.

Chapter two: Pillar 2: Place each risk where it first becomes visible

Take the strategic risks already on the board's register and ask one question of each: at which stage does this risk first become visible? A risk often begins in one place and reaches others. Record the first stage as its home, and list the later stages it spreads to in a separate column. The distinction matters for ownership, because the owner of the home stage is usually the first person who can act. A risk that spreads across four stages with no home stage will be discussed in four meetings and resolved in none.

Tie each placement to evidence rather than to opinion. The Financial Stability Board estimates private credit at $1.5–2 trillion in assets, and says that private credit supports financing for mid-sized companies while also creating potential financial stability risks. A mid-sized company that relies on that kind of funding has a financing stage on its map, and a funding-source risk belongs there, with a note of what the funding source would do under stress. NIST makes a related point about its own materials: it says its resources overlap and share themes. That is a reason to place each risk once and reuse the placement across any standard or regulator who asks, rather than building a separate register for each one.

Chapter three: Pillar 3: Give each stage-risk one named owner

Ownership is where most mapping exercises fail. A committee can discuss a risk, but a committee cannot fix a supplier, hire a surgeon or renegotiate a lease. Each stage-risk needs exactly one owner, and that owner needs the authority to change something at the stage: a budget line, a contract, a staffing decision or a reporting threshold. The test is simple. Ask the proposed owner to name the single decision they could take this quarter that would change the risk. If they cannot name one, they do not own the risk. If two people each say the risk is theirs, neither owns it.

Owners also need a line of sight to the people who set the rules. The Basel Committee, which the Bank for International Settlements presents as the primary global standard setter for bank prudential regulation, describes itself as a forum for regular cooperation on banking supervisory matters, and it has 45 members made up of central banks and bank supervisors. The lesson for a non-bank is practical. Where a regulator, supervisor or external body sets a rule that bears on a stage-risk, name the person who keeps in touch with that body. That person should be the owner or report to the owner, and their contact should be written in the register, so the board knows who would be called first.

Chapter four: Pillar 4: Write a mitigation you can test

A mitigation is a commitment that a board can check. It has three parts: a threshold that defines when the risk has become a problem, a date by which the mitigation will be in place, and a measure that shows whether it works. The phrase “improve supplier resilience” fails all three tests. The phrase “qualify a second supplier for the critical input by the end of next quarter, and report the share of volume that supplier could cover” passes them. If a mitigation cannot be written with a number, the owner should say so openly, and the board should treat the risk as one it is accepting rather than one it is managing.

Use materiality as the filter for what reaches the board. The IFRS homepage describes an FSA Credential that assesses materiality of sustainability information for corporate performance and investment analysis, delivered through two exams. The credential is aimed at analysts, but the discipline is useful to a board. Ask whether a stage-risk, if it went wrong, would change a decision that the board or an investor would make. If it would not, the risk can stay in the stage plan. If it would, it belongs on the strategic page with its owner, threshold, date and measure. This keeps the register short enough to be read in a board meeting.

Seven questions to test the map

Answer each question yes or no. Any no is a gap to close before the next board meeting.

  • Does the chain have between five and eight stages, each with one named executive?
  • Is every strategic risk placed on the stage where it first becomes visible?
  • Does each stage-risk have exactly one owner with authority to change that stage?
  • Can each owner name one decision they could take this quarter that would change the risk?
  • Does each mitigation have a threshold, a date and a measure?
  • Has the owner named any external regulator, supervisor or supplier that the mitigation dep
  • Would each stage-risk on the strategic page change a decision the board or an investor wou

Outgrace checklist

Where it breaks

Three failures are common, in our experience. The first is a map drawn once and never revisited, so that the stages describe the business as it was two years ago. The second is ownership by committee, which produces minutes but no decisions. The third is a mitigation that describes activity, such as a review or a working group, rather than an effect that can be measured. Each of these can be caught by the checklist above, but none of them is caught by a long register.

The limits of the sources also matter. The four sources used here are the NIST Cybersecurity Framework page, Financial Stability Board material, the Basel Committee page on the BIS site, and the IFRS homepage. None of them addresses healthcare, health-system regulation or value-chain mapping, and none describes a stage-by-stage method for assigning risk ownership. The method above is therefore a structure, not a standard. Before adopting any threshold, check the sector-specific rules with your regulator and with your own risk function. The sources do disagree with each other on nothing we could find on their overlapping points, but that is a narrow check, and it does not make the method suitable for a particular health system.

On Monday, pick one value chain. Draw its stages in an afternoon with the finance lead and the operations lead in the room, and resist the urge to add a ninth. Place the three strategic risks the board worries about most, record their first stage and their spread, and give each one an owner. Ask each owner for one mitigation with a threshold, a date and a measure. Bring the result to the next board meeting as a single page. The page will be less impressive than a register, and far more useful.

Newsletter

The Briefing

One email a week: the leaders we profiled, the ideas worth stealing, and nothing else.

Weekly, free, one click to leave. Read our privacy policy.